I would love to see it become the norm to indicate how people came to make a recommendation (for a breeder and when people recommend rescues too).
Is it from meeting the dogs from that breeder with their owners, seeing the dogs in a show, competition, having a dog from that breeder, visiting the breeder?
Is it from reading their website?
Seeing pictures?
Seeing people on this forum with their dogs but never having met the person or the dogs?
Is it from knowledge of the pedigree and lines? (I love these discussions and find them so interesting so always look to see what people are saying about these things)
Yada, yada, yada.
Because that makes a huge difference, I would imagine, if you are the person taking in these recommendations.
It would be like asking for a restaurant recommendation when you go on vacation. And I say well, I heard that Joe's Fancy Eats is great. Have I eaten there? No. Seen the food in person? No. Then you find out that I only eat frozen food so don't even have the basic knowledge of the types of food they serve. Except instead of a bad meal, you end up with a dog that's not a match for you, or support bad practices, or whatever.
I would love to see people put a qualifier - why they think that this is a good breeder to recommend. Not your resume or anything - just some way for people who have only posted 1 or 2x on this board to get an idea of who is making the recommendation. It would just be a throw-in sentence - like:
Wolfstraum - have met 3 of her dogs, seen them in sport and social situations and really liked their attitude
Zu Treuen Händen- have never met any of the dogs or her, but shares similar dog values and really seems to be a student of the breed and breeding
Acme German Shepherds - have only looked at their website and pictures on facebook but they are gorgeous dogs
Also, I am just a dog lover, so take my recommendation for what it is.
Or, if people can't/won't do that, if you are making that first or second post asking for help, ask the people why they recommend these dogs, what their experience is with them, and where they are coming from in making those recs. Same with rescues.
Maybe?!?
Is it from meeting the dogs from that breeder with their owners, seeing the dogs in a show, competition, having a dog from that breeder, visiting the breeder?
Is it from reading their website?
Seeing pictures?
Seeing people on this forum with their dogs but never having met the person or the dogs?
Is it from knowledge of the pedigree and lines? (I love these discussions and find them so interesting so always look to see what people are saying about these things)
Yada, yada, yada.
Because that makes a huge difference, I would imagine, if you are the person taking in these recommendations.
It would be like asking for a restaurant recommendation when you go on vacation. And I say well, I heard that Joe's Fancy Eats is great. Have I eaten there? No. Seen the food in person? No. Then you find out that I only eat frozen food so don't even have the basic knowledge of the types of food they serve. Except instead of a bad meal, you end up with a dog that's not a match for you, or support bad practices, or whatever.
I would love to see people put a qualifier - why they think that this is a good breeder to recommend. Not your resume or anything - just some way for people who have only posted 1 or 2x on this board to get an idea of who is making the recommendation. It would just be a throw-in sentence - like:
Wolfstraum - have met 3 of her dogs, seen them in sport and social situations and really liked their attitude
Zu Treuen Händen- have never met any of the dogs or her, but shares similar dog values and really seems to be a student of the breed and breeding
Acme German Shepherds - have only looked at their website and pictures on facebook but they are gorgeous dogs
Also, I am just a dog lover, so take my recommendation for what it is.
Or, if people can't/won't do that, if you are making that first or second post asking for help, ask the people why they recommend these dogs, what their experience is with them, and where they are coming from in making those recs. Same with rescues.
Maybe?!?