If my brother kicked my puppy, he would have my size 9-1/2EEEE shoe implanted on his backside!
Isn't it nice that the internet has shrunk the world, and no longer is being from a different country or culture an excuse for not having information available?
The reason we get on a message board and ask a question is because we think that what the people around us are telling us about something might not be right or the best way to go about something.
Kicking a puppy can make it fearful and unpredictably aggressive. Train and socialize your puppy so that he has plenty of experiences to draw from, if he in an ok but strange experience he will not do something that is not wanted. When he is old enough he can be trained for protection work, though I like the idea of geese in the yard much better.
I agree with everyone else, a GSD is no match for a gun-toting bad guy. My GSDs determ house breakers, as they are looking for an easy buck. They will generally see the dog and find another house to break into. Having a dog that will bark its head off every time anyone comes near the dwelling is worth something.
Lastly, GSDFan, I would rather people say directly what they mean, and not find a nicer way to say something. I think that befuddles stuff too much. Giving a one liner saying that the OP does not deserve a dog, or writing three paragraphs that boil down to the OP does not deserve a dog, well the one-liner can easily be agreed with or disagreed with. And the chances are the longer sweeter post is much more likely to be misunderstood by one or more people.
I think that we cannot judge by the post whether he deserves a GSD for the following reason:
Let's say I just bought my first working line shepherd from a well-known working line shepherd producer. It is nine weeks old, and I intend to train it for schutzhund. Should I wait until the dog is 18 months old to ask what I need to do? I should be on the Schutzhund thread NOW asking how I should raise this dog differently than my pets, what games to play, what situations I should avoid, what early training I should do.
This guy bought a puppy he intends to grow into a good guard dog from guard dog sire and dam. He is asking how to go about getting him to that level. It kills us to hear how do I make my puppy aggressive. But if the same question was framed differently, I intend to train this puppy for schutzhund, specifically protection work, what do I need to do with him, I think the answers would have been different.
He is not kicking the puppy, his brother is. Nothing wrong with us telling him to put his brother in a coma for then next eighteen months. But what he wants to know is whether this will be a problem when it comes time to train the puppy for guarding. And many of you did say that the pup will be fine so long as it stops NOW. And I tend to agree. The puppy will likely forget this first traumatic week.