This is my favorite: Treat Pouch Sport

 

This is my favorite: Treat Pouch Sport

Is the hinge holding out ok? I liked the looks of this one, but there were several reviews on Amazon saying the hinges broke apart soon.

 

i have these…

• Ruffwear Treat Trader
• Doggone Good Rapid Rewards
• Petsafe Treat Pouch (hinge)

of the three, the only one i love is Doggone Good Rapid Rewards…
Do not like the Ruffwear one at all, although i stand by most of their products. My main complaint is that the in/out entry isn’t smooth. To be fair, i have rather large hands (for a woman).

 

I was kind of leaning toward the Rapid Rewards one too. Like you, my hands are kind of large too. My fingers are short but hands are large. Any kind of gloves, including disposable gloves, I have to buy large.

 

I use the Ruffwear. I like that it doesn't zip, but opens and closes with a hinge that gives me easy access.
Sheilah

 

 

I've tried lining my own pockets with a plastic bag. Sadly not many of my pants or shirts have decent pockets. I used a shirt pocket once. That worked well but now each time I wear that shirt the dogs hope for rewards

 

Any treat bag with magnets not a zipper is my favourite so look for one with quick release magnets the best ones are that also a pocket for doggie bags also a clip I use this one

EzyDog Treat Pouch Snak Pak Treat Bag

Always have a pet snack and poop bag handy with a useful treat pouch from ExyDog

www.petbarn.com.au

 

Any treat bag with magnets not a zipper is my favourite so look for one with quick release magnets the best ones are that also a pocket for doggie bags also a clip I use this one

EzyDog Treat Pouch Snak Pak Treat Bag

Always have a pet snack and poop bag handy with a useful treat pouch from ExyDog

www.petbarn.com.au

Looked it up. Think it will be a bit small for my hands.

 

<----cheap ... lazy .... but would probably do this. I haven't actually used a treat pouch ... I use the sophisticated and streamlined item that @WNGD posted and stick it in a jacket pocket. I've also used my money pouch in a pinch.

 

<----cheap ... lazy .... but would probably do this.

I actually tried that years ok. It was ok to use in a slow moving class, but not for quick access.

 

Hi Rosebud99!

I like to wear the treat pouch around my waist and close to my back too. Of the brands you’ve listed I’ve only tried the Petsafe treat pouch and I’ve gone through about 4 of those (broken belt clip, poked a hole).

I’ve been using K9 Tactical Gear’s Training pouch since 2019 and it’s still going strong. The sturdy metal belt clip is still tight on my 1.5 inch heavy-duty webbing belt. No problems with the hinge either. It can hold what I typically carry on walks: a small first aid kit (tweezers, gauze, small bandage), cellphone, spare dominant dog collar, whistle, Boker subcom knife, toy of the day for obedience work mid walk (tug toy, ball on a rope, scent tin for nose work) and of course..treats lol.

Link: Training Bag

Old pictures:

 

tried the Petsafe treat pouch and I’ve gone through about 4 of those (broken belt clip, poked a hole).

I’ve been using K9 Tactical Gear’s Training pouch since 2019 and it’s still going strong. The sturdy metal belt clip is still tight on my 1.5 inch heavy-duty webbing belt. No problems with the hinge either. It can hold what I typically carry on walks: a small first aid kit (tweezers, gauze, small bandage), cellphone, spare dominant dog collar, whistle, Boker subcom knife, toy of the day for obedience work mid walk (tug toy, ball on a rope, scent tin for nose work) and of course..treats lol.

Link: Training Bag

Wow! You fit a lot of stuff in there!

I checked it out and the 3.5" wide opening makes it a no go for me.

 

I like the Leerburg one best, but prefer a vest to a treat pouch.

 

I ordered this one and I love it:

PET N PET Dog Treat Training Pouch-3 Ways to Wear Dog Treat Pouch with Built-in Poop Bag Dispenser-(3 Rolls Poop Bags Included) https://a.co/d/f4LPRHK

I can fit tons of treats and just tighten the tie to close it when I need to. Lots of little pockets I use for their prong collars, and it goes right around my waist so it doesn't fall off.

I had a magnetic one too and loved it but it just clipped on and would always fall off, I ended up losing it somewhere

 

I tried many pouches but ended up using pockets. If I train and or go on a longer walk I use a vest.

 

aren't your treats already in a bag? Duke does not care where they come from, long as they keep coming.

 

LOL! But where do you keep the bag....

 

Not mine

 

Good to know.

 

I saw this one gaining some popularity, I plan to order it myself to try it out, like the simplicity and the easy to clean factor, I hate the cinch ones!

RoyalCare Silicone Dog Treat Pouch-Small Training Bag-Portable Dog Treat Bag for Leash with Magnetic Closure and Waist Clip[US Design Patent] https://a.co/d/hMagKye

 

I know one thats been gaining popularity thats silicone and has a magnet that holds it together,

I've seen that one online. Personally I don't like the "feel" of silicone anything....just me.

 

I like the idea of an apron. That will work down the line. Right now with working on the basics Frankie pays too much attention to the treat bag if I have it in front or on my side. That's why I want one that would be easy to dig into with it against my back, further away from his nose, lol.

 

I'm still undecided on a treat bag. I just did a little "test" with a small cross body bag I have. Based on that, the most comfortable opening for me for a treat pouch would be 6" wide. Online description rarely specify the size of the opening. If anyone has one with that size opening I'd love to hear,

 

LOL! But where do you keep the bag....

in the cupboard. The one Duke takes everyone to.

 

I got one of these, its a chalk bag but works great as a treat bag and looks cool too

Halcon Chalk Bag - Del Día

The Halcon comes with all the features you’d expect in a premium chalk bag—a structured rim opening for easy access, adjustable drawstring closure, a soft fleece interior, and an elastic brush loop—and adds some very nice details. The body-facing side of the bag features an elastic mesh pocket...

www.cotopaxi.com

 

I read somewhere else about chalk bags. Forgot to look at those.

 

I totally get your struggle with finding the perfect treat pouch – it can be a real challenge. From your description, it sounds like you want something super convenient and reliable. Have you considered checking out https://www.interplas.com? They have a variety of options, and you might find one that fits your criteria perfectly. I personally haven't used one with a magnet closure, but it sounds like a great idea for quick access to treats. The wider-than-high design also makes total sense for easy reach.

 

My favorite ones are washable. I just had to throw out an old treat bag because it got moldy inside and I couldn’t wash it.