German Shepherds Forum banner

PANDA shepherd?????

58K views 101 replies 36 participants last post by  berno von der seeweise  
#1 ·
#40 ·
When they created the cutesy name they opened themselves up for the criticism. They are a GSD of an unusual tri-type coloring. Panda Shepherd just comes across as a cute marketing tool just like all the idiot 'doodles" and other cross breed names that have been created. When I see that name my first reaction is $$$$$$$$$$$.
 
#44 ·
When they created the cutesy name they opened themselves up for the criticism. They are a GSD of an unusual tri-type coloring. Panda Shepherd just comes across as a cute marketing tool just like all the idiot 'doodles" and other cross breed names that have been created. When I see that name my first reaction is $$$$$$$$$$$.
From one of the 4 breeders websites:
"Naming the dogs with this pattern the "Panda Shepherd" was for the benefit of those who would condemn us for calling these dogs GSDs."

Also, if it was all about marketing and money don't you think she'd be pumping out Panda's left and right or at least charging ridiculous prices for the dogs? This breeder can't catch a break.
 
#41 ·
If you think about it, though, all the colors/patterns have different names. White, liver, blue, bi-color, black/red, black/tan, sable, blanket back, etc....
 
#42 ·
But they are not cutesy names. They depict the color. Panda (which they look nothing like) is cutesy.
 
#45 ·
It is documented? Fine. But 15 years ago, I would not trust DNA, and I really didn't think that DNA for determining breed was all that accurate. So a breeder witnessed these pups whelped, but a litter can have more than one sire. And more like, the sire or dam of the litter looked all GSD, and the breeders probably believe that he was all GSD, but isn't it possible that one or the other was 1/4 or 1/8 something else, like husky. Someone somewhere did not realize some mangy, rangy husky or border collie mix bred their bred female, and out of the litter, a pup that looks all GSD is actually 1/2 a mixture.

I am just thinking that as possible as it is for this to just happen, like the big bang, it is also possible that someone somewhere was not so careful as they thought with their bitch. I just am not convinced that this is a purebred GSD.

I am surprised they are not calling them pie-bald. I do not like the look. But I don't like culling for aesthetics either. I just would not breed for it, as they are.

The brindle used to be a color in GSDs and it is no longer. I would think that if this color just cropped up out of nothingness, some dogs somewhere would just come out brindle too.
 
#46 ·
Sue,
The dogs were bred on the premises of the breeder.....both parents were her dogs.
There was no "outside" mongrel, huskie or phantom stud that shared his sperm in making of the litter. This was a 40acre homestead and ALL dogs were in indoor/outdoor 25 ft runs. The property was also fenced in.
Believe it or not....the litter was purebred, and from the parents she owned....
Culling happened much more yester-year than it does today...but you will find, from talking to breeders of yester-year, that there are MANY things that are kept as skeletons in the closet.
One would be surprised to know how many "imperfections" happen when breeding......that's the reality of *genes*, both recessive, dominant and dormant....they DO present themselves from time to time...
 
#47 ·
The parents of the litter were tested through DNA. This tests works. It is why sires utilized a certain amount must submit DNA to AKC. The parents of all the black and tan pups were also the parents of the tri-colored one in the litter. This type of DNA test determines parenatge. It is why a litter can have two sires and then the testing used to sort out whose is whose.

The Pandas are a GSD of a different color only. Genes are fun!
 
#48 ·
Linda Shaw was fairly interested in the panda , a name which I think is awful , in that it is cutesy . Really it is a PIED or PIEBALD .
Apparently she visited the Ontario breeder who found Pied pups in her litter and confirmed that DNA "paternity" test was done , there was one sire , and the sire of the Pied (panda) was the sire of note . No mystery misters.

Page 126 - after von Stephanitz has written about "the foundation colour is a wolf-like dark shading on a grey-yellow grond from which all other colours, from the pure white, (which, however, is very seldom seen in smooth-haired dogs , and is then not beautiful), up to uniform black. have been develope. the most frequent are the wolf-colourd, that is to say, the sandy or the sandy grey, or pale red to brown coloured dogs with regular, mostly light tan points on the head and limbs; one can also see black and sandy coloured dogs i.e. black doges wiht the same markings , but mostly a more pronouned darker tan to reddish brown colouring.

xxxxxxxxxxxxx Dapple blue fellows were formerly often met with among the working dogs in nortern and central Germany, expecially BLUE or RED WITH WHITE PATCHES. In Brunswick some sheep farmers, have a specila liking for dogs with a particular tiger-spotted coat. These dogs had dark brown ot black spots or larger splashes on a lighter background .

Illustration page 129 figure 107 a smooth haired dog from Brunswick - flaked blue grey -- 128 long ocat shepherd dog from Saxony - flaked blue-grey. Page 130 another picture of "spotted "
 
#49 ·
this was interesting Frankenhaus German Shepherds - Color Genetics

When the GSD was made into one unified breed , as per any public registry dog, standards were set that went out side of function , performance and into the cosmetic . Although v Stephanitz said there is no good dog with a bad colour , it was clear that certain variations of colour were to be discriminated against, not bred from . These included, white, liver, blue , patterns , merle , even brindle which was continued with a common ancestor to evolve into the Dutch Shepherd.
What is in the genes is not lost , only hidden .
 
#51 ·
A normal German Shepherd is one of the five(?) colors: red, black, sable, tan, etc. Not panda. Panda I consider, as well as white, as a genetic mutation that is not a normal dog. As pretty as they are, pandas are not "real" German shepherds in my book.
 
#53 ·
A normal German Shepherd is one of the five(?) colors: red, black, sable, tan, etc. Not panda. Panda I consider, as well as white, as a genetic mutation that is not a normal dog.
The panda markings are the result of a mutation. White is a naturally occurring color in the breed, not a mutation.
Pandas are not recognized by AKC or the other big dog places, but it's kind of opinionated. Some people think they are shepherds. I don't personally.
The AKC doesn't recognize a breed known as the "Panda Shepherd" that's true, but a dog with panda markings can be registered as a GSD if it is in fact a purebred GSD. (meaning it's pedigree shows it's a GSD)
 
#57 ·
My take is that they are a German Shepherd, but just one with a fault. I do not prefer them either though.

What makes a purebred is if all ancestors are members of the breed. They are purebred German Shepherds. You test their DNA and it will say the same.

There is no perfect dog. One does not exist. However, choosing to breed in that genetic trait is not one that many are likely to make. The panda genetic mutation is dominant so it's very easy to avoid if one wants to.

Saying that one particular fault makes a dog no longer a German Shepherd is a bit harsh. To me it is like saying that a dog with low withers, doesn't have parallel head planes, is too friendly, gets startled by loud noises, cow hocked, or otherwise isn't a German Shepherd either. One fault doesn't make it no longer a German Shepherd.

A severe fault like panda would still make it a less ideal specimen of the breed though.
 
#59 ·
I just found this one and decided to put my two cents in. Probably more like one cent. :)

I do think Pandas are genetically German Shepherds, the thing is: some people consider a mutation good to the point where they breed them. I don't think that's the case one bit. I don't think the animal that is mutated should be bred at all to continue the gene that caused the mutation, even if the mutation is just color. No matter how "pretty" it is. Some people have whole kennels full to the brim with panda shepherds. That's like breeding two cow-hocked German shepherds and calling the outcome a "new form" of shepherd. It's just not right.

You can tell I feel quite strongly about this. ?

German shepherds should never be panda, and I would never breed one like some people do.
 
#62 · (Edited)
@Jax08

it took me one minute to find this. I can't stand places like this. They had a liver/panda shepherd there!!! :mad: Livers are considered very bad when it comes to German Shepherds, but you probably already know that.
 
#63 ·

it took me one minute to find this. I can't stand places like this. They had a liver/panda shepherd there!!! :mad: Livers are considered very bad when it comes to German Shepherds, but you probably already know that.
Not suggesting they should be bred, but do you know why they're considered bad?
 
#64 ·
Why are Livers considered very bad? Yes the color is not in the standard but they do pop up in good litters. Nothing is "bad" unless you are breeding out of the standard purposely. The breeder of my male had a liver in one of her litters. That dog is doing sport and living a good life. He just won't be bred.
 
#65 ·
@ Jax08:


The first few look okay, but scroll down and you'll get blues, husky colored ones, SOLID LIVERS, and total panda everywhere. Not to mention to the prong collars so loose that you could take it off the dog's head with two inches of room to spare. Talk about unprofessional!

(this drives me really nuts.)

Whiteshepherds: "Coat Colors that are: "Pale or Washed Out, Blues, Livers are Serious Faults" -http://vonkazmaier.com/?id=689 (a professional GSD site)

Marked as "other" in AKC registrations. Don't know why liver is bad, it just isn't recommended or liked among good breeders or the AKC.
 
#75 ·
Marked as "other" in AKC registrations.
The AKC registration form has a section for color. I guess someone can write down "other" (??) but the AKC does provide data for the following colors in the GSD breed; Bi-Color, Black, Black/Cream, Black/Red, Black/Silver, Black/Tan, Blue, Gray, Liver, Sable, Tan, White

They are very slack with their standards compared to USCA and SV.
The content of the SV vs AKC breed standards aren't all that different, they're just formatted differently.
 
#67 ·
I think before having an opinion, you need to understand the why.

First, I keep my prong collar loose depending on what I'm doing. Second, I don't need to look at the links. I know what colors are standard, what is not and why. The only reason liver and blues are not accepted is the leather on a shepherd has to be black. Liver and blues have faded leather. Their noses are either grey or brown depending on the color. LIver and blue come from a dilute gene. Liver is a dilute. Blue is a double dilute. Some people think the blue comes with skin issues but that is not true. It may in other breeds but not in the GSD.

Again - anyone that breeds purposely for dogs not of the standard is not a good thing. Color, size, working ability, etc. However, the colors can pop up on litters from good breeders because those are recessive genes that are part of our breed. It doesn't make the dog bad. Just means they shouldn't be bred. My male's father has had a liver pop up in a litter. He's the 2015 WUSV champion. It happens sometimes and good breeders put those dogs in homes that won't breed them.
 
#70 ·
I kind of thought so.
I'm not saying dogs who are not within breed standard should be disposed of or anything, I'm just saying that the people that breed those pop-ups are really unprofessional and that I do not believe that is good.

Also, if you have a prong collar on a working dog that is so loose that it is lying on the shoulders with inches to spare, that is someone who has not learned how to used a prong collar, or who is not taking it off after a training lesson. That. Is bad.
 
#71 ·