Hi All, my 8 month old girl Athena was originally being fed adult food by the breeder however she has always been thin and the vet recommended puppy food. I have had her eating Victor Hi Pro Plus for the last 3 months or so which she likes. I feed her 2 cups per day and sometimes supplement that with a couple of tablespoons of cottage cheese as she is still pretty thin. She doesn't have any other issues as far as health is concerned but she has this strange habit of pooping outside and then when I bring her in she will poop again on the carpet. She does this about half of the time. It's difficult because I live in the Seattle area (lots of cold rainy nights) where sometimes at night I take her out and she will poop right away. I praise her, and then walk her around for a while. Sometimes she will poop again. Most times I eventually bring her in and then 30 minutes later she will poop on the floor. Her poop does seem pretty hard and comes out in small sort of pieces. I'm wondering if maybe I should try a different high quality food.