German Shepherds Forum banner

Status
Not open for further replies.
21 - 39 of 39 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,319 Posts
they may say more than that, and that's why im here to learn... but they certainly got interested probably from those reasons. If you have an excellent health dog with high potential why wouldn't you want to learn about breeding at least to know your options and also get her properly vetted and trained?
There is a very strong possibility your dog isn't purebred. Find that out first. Wait until she is over age two and get her hips and elbows certified, check for DM. Title her in something respected. Then come back and ask about breeding. You aren't there yet.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
31,369 Posts
All of those qualities come basically from a very strong and healthy dog that is trained well. .
No. Those qualities come from genetics. Either the dog has them or he doesn't.

A healthy and strong dog does not mean a dog with balanced drives and nerve. An unhealthy and weak dog does not mean the dog doesn't have strong nerves.

You can not train drives and nerve into a dog. They are what they are.

I don't think you have a grasp on what makes a dog breed worthy, what drives are, what nerve is, and the only way to learn that is to get off the internet, go out and train your dog. Watch the other dogs. Talk to knowledgeable people.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
533 Posts
A dog is not breed worthy based on perceived potential. I bet your dog is a good dog, prove it by getting her health tested (actual x-rays of hips/elbows being sent to OFA or SV and given a passing score, DM test, ect.) and use her great potential to train her in something challenging out in public. How a dog acts in it's own home or comfort zone is not a good indication of it's nerves. If a dog has such great potential it's a shame not to allow that dog to live up to it.

Get educated on the breed, know the breed standard and be open minded and ready to learn because most people with pet GSDs have no clue. There are a lot of GSD experts out there, many on these forums that are a wealth of information. I understand that wanting to have and raise puppies is something enjoyable and fun but in this day and age when thousands of dogs are put to sleep everyday we need to be smart and responsible about our decisions. Bringing 6-12 more puppies into this world is a big responsibility. Bringing 6-12 puppies with unknown health history and unknown temperament into this world is just impulsive and careless.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
31,877 Posts
If you ask a breeder what their purpose is in breeding this bitch to this dog, they should be able to give you an answer. There should be some methodology to the selection of bitch and dog, and a direction in which the breeder is going. The selection should take into consideration the bloodlines as well as the individual dogs, what the dogs produce not just what traits they have, and if you have been working on it for a while, what traits a dog improves, not just what traits the dog possesses.

Each of my questions was asked simply and directly, not to "discourage" but to encourage you to do it right, to educate yourself, and to get connected with someone who will help you out.

The place to meet the people you need are training clubs, training classes. And don't expect it to happen over-night. If you picked an excellent breeder from the beginning that wasn't too far away, then cultivate that relationship, and learn from them, learn about them before you decide. It sometimes takes getting dirty, spending time in classes and in clubs before a breeder believes you are serious enough and have something to offer, for them to accept you as someone they want to help learn.

There are a few breeders here. Carmen already wrote you off pretty much. This just isn't a venue to mentor people to become breeders. You can't train and evaluate dogs over a computer, and you can't breed a bitch or whelp a litter over the computer. At 2 AM when your bitch is circling and straining, if you come on here, there might be one or two newbies that will scream at you to get to the vet, which may or may not be the thing to do.

Sorry, I am just telling it like it is. You are taking it as though it is discouraging. Discouraged over words isn't a good start, really. I know a lady who waited years for a pup, and then trained her in all kinds of things only to find she had HD. Ok, she kept her and loved her and got a second pup, and did the same, only to have some other heritable disease. She kept her and loved her, and waited for a few more years and put in another shepherd only to have her hopes dashed yet again. Another lady lost her bitch and had to hand-raise the puppies. And a friend of mine nearly lost her bitch and all the puppies. Talk about discouraging. Ah well, some things we are just determined to learn the hard way.

My mentor, a lady that was breeding and raising champions before I was born, half a century, would say to me, "I have to learn from other people's mistakes, I don't have time to make them all myself."
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
123 Posts
Discussion Starter #27
A dog is not breed worthy based on perceived potential. I bet your dog is a good dog, prove it by getting her health tested (actual x-rays of hips/elbows being sent to OFA or SV and given a passing score, DM test, ect.) and use her great potential to train her in something challenging out in public. How a dog acts in it's own home or comfort zone is not a good indication of it's nerves. If a dog has such great potential it's a shame not to allow that dog to live up to it.

Get educated on the breed, know the breed standard and be open minded and ready to learn because most people with pet GSDs have no clue. There are a lot of GSD experts out there, many on these forums that are a wealth of information. I understand that wanting to have and raise puppies is something enjoyable and fun but in this day and age when thousands of dogs are put to sleep everyday we need to be smart and responsible about our decisions. Bringing 6-12 more puppies into this world is a big responsibility. Bringing 6-12 puppies with unknown health history and unknown temperament into this world is just impulsive and careless.
Dude, people just cannot read without being completely straight forward about the exact last reply when I've been saying obviously I have to prove it and I'm here to ask the avenues to do so...............................................................................................................................
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
123 Posts
Discussion Starter #28
If you ask a breeder what their purpose is in breeding this bitch to this dog, they should be able to give you an answer. There should be some methodology to the selection of bitch and dog, and a direction in which the breeder is going. The selection should take into consideration the bloodlines as well as the individual dogs, what the dogs produce not just what traits they have, and if you have been working on it for a while, what traits a dog improves, not just what traits the dog possesses.

Each of my questions was asked simply and directly, not to "discourage" but to encourage you to do it right, to educate yourself, and to get connected with someone who will help you out.

The place to meet the people you need are training clubs, training classes. And don't expect it to happen over-night. If you picked an excellent breeder from the beginning that wasn't too far away, then cultivate that relationship, and learn from them, learn about them before you decide. It sometimes takes getting dirty, spending time in classes and in clubs before a breeder believes you are serious enough and have something to offer, for them to accept you as someone they want to help learn.

There are a few breeders here. Carmen already wrote you off pretty much. This just isn't a venue to mentor people to become breeders. You can't train and evaluate dogs over a computer, and you can't breed a bitch or whelp a litter over the computer. At 2 AM when your bitch is circling and straining, if you come on here, there might be one or two newbies that will scream at you to get to the vet, which may or may not be the thing to do.

Sorry, I am just telling it like it is. You are taking it as though it is discouraging. Discouraged over words isn't a good start, really. I know a lady who waited years for a pup, and then trained her in all kinds of things only to find she had HD. Ok, she kept her and loved her and got a second pup, and did the same, only to have some other heritable disease. She kept her and loved her, and waited for a few more years and put in another shepherd only to have her hopes dashed yet again. Another lady lost her bitch and had to hand-raise the puppies. And a friend of mine nearly lost her bitch and all the puppies. Talk about discouraging. Ah well, some things we are just determined to learn the hard way.

My mentor, a lady that was breeding and raising champions before I was born, half a century, would say to me, "I have to learn from other people's mistakes, I don't have time to make them all myself."
And Im here to figure that out everyone has to start somehwere.

the way youre posting basically being skeptical rather than just te4lling me staright instead of constantly doubting is not helping. I dont need opinions just facts.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
123 Posts
Discussion Starter #31
Winnal, WTF, in one forum you ask if your dog is purebred and in the next you want to breed????? Really, or is this an early April fool's joke
From that post we established grounds that she could be pure if I get dna tested for sire and sire is dna recorded so there's little reason for them to lie about the sire. and someone said they auto get dna'd after certain amount of litter, what does that matter if it provides proof?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,381 Posts
Fact: Until you x-ray your dog and have her checked for DM, you will not know if she can pass on genetic faults.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
123 Posts
Discussion Starter #33
No. Those qualities come from genetics. Either the dog has them or he doesn't.

A healthy and strong dog does not mean a dog with balanced drives and nerve. An unhealthy and weak dog does not mean the dog doesn't have strong nerves.

You can not train drives and nerve into a dog. They are what they are.

I don't think you have a grasp on what makes a dog breed worthy, what drives are, what nerve is, and the only way to learn that is to get off the internet, go out and train your dog. Watch the other dogs. Talk to knowledgeable people.
So why are you on here then? on the internet?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
123 Posts
Discussion Starter #34
Fact: Until you x-ray your dog and have her checked for DM, you will not know if she can pass on genetic faults.
there are signs of hp displasia for example like their stance, that's all ime saying
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,381 Posts
From that post we established grounds that she could be pure if I get dna tested for sire and sire is dna recorded so there's little reason for them to lie about the sire. and someone said they auto get dna'd after certain amount of litter, what does that matter if it provides proof?
Fact: If you have her DNA'd by AKC they will check if her DNA matches the sire's, who is on record, and then and only then will you know she is the daughter of that sire.


Fact: You can send in a general DNA test to a company to see what breed they say she is.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
533 Posts
Dude, people just cannot read without being completely straight forward about the exact last reply when I've been saying obviously I have to prove it and I'm here to ask the avenues to do so...............................................................................................................................
Hey dude, pretty obvious you are just trolling this forum. Making 4 posts one after another about the same thing trying to incite drama. Contradicting yourself in multiple posts. I think we all just need to ignore this one at this point.
Really liking this new ignore feature on the forum
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
123 Posts
Discussion Starter #38 (Edited)
That's an opinion, you said you wanted facts.


Fact: I had a dog with Hip Dysplasia. You could NOT tell by her stance.
umm i said signs tho not 100% positive... not really an opinion i read it up on a narticle about dog health specifically hip dysplasia

and that link about drive and temperment, my dog has excellent prey drive, and defense drive.. hear sound aroudn house goes running barking... chases anything small that moves fast...

and nerve wise she doesn't really get scared of anything. at all. never backs up stands ground and all her hairs on the top of her back like a mohawk stands up.

im obviously not professionally versed in understanding it by any means but i do have an idea what it means.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
37 Posts
Forgive me if this has been brought up or if I'm wrong, but don't you need a full registration to breed and get AKC-registered puppies? From what I remember, full registration can only be obtained with the breeder's permission (and is more expensive than the limited registration). I don't know if you have one or not, Winnal, but that's another thing to think about/be aware of :)
 
21 - 39 of 39 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top