German Shepherds Forum banner

1 - 15 of 15 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,594 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Hi All,
I think the entire “GSD Rescue Information” forum is awesome and I’m grateful to admin, the moderators and member for all of the work they do to sustain it. But I’d like to see it reorganized to help us find the dogs that currently need to be rescued from shelters and ultimately adopted.
For instance, the dogs in “Urgent” who are adopted or PTS could be moved to a new section “Adopted or PTS” and instead of remaining in the “Urgent” section listed as “moved” they would be removed from “Urgent” altogether immediately. That way the “Urgent” section would only list the current Urgent dogs. Dogs not adopted or PTS but still need follow up could be moved to “Non-Urgent GSD Rescue & Adoption” then only current dogs needing follow up would be listed. This would eliminate the “Follow-up from” section.
I’m interested to see what others think. Just give it some thought….
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
24,301 Posts
I think you are seeing/not liking the redirects that are there so that people looking for the thread for a while can still find it. You can probably see redirects in the General Information forum as an example.

We can make it so that there are no redirects to another forum (follow up, rescue stories if dogs are adopted or PTS, non-urgent if going to a known rescue) but then people might not be able to find a thread they are looking for in the week or two that people are generally thinking of it. So that is something to discuss/think about.

I am going to move this thread without a redirect so that you can look at the Suggestion/Comment box and then find it.
So that you can see what I mean. This isn't a big deal when it shows up on active topics, or is a topic you posted to, but when it is one you are following but haven't checked on for a while, it can be harder to locate. So go check out the Suggestion/Comment box, then look at somewhere like General Info - yours is totally gone, poof, there are all sorts of arrows in General Info. And that's what you see in the rescue section - thread name and redirect.

Dogs not adopted or PTS but still need follow up could be moved to “Non-Urgent GSD Rescue & Adoption” then only current dogs needing follow up would be listed. This would eliminate the “Follow-up from” section.
Dogs not adopted or PTS that are in Urgent are dogs that are going to be PTS - in imminent danger - so we should not move them. If there are dogs posted that are not in imminent danger, they should be in non-urgent and be notified on anyway.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,594 Posts
Discussion Starter #3
.

Dogs not adopted or PTS that are in Urgent are dogs that are going to be PTS - in imminent danger - so we should not move them. If there are dogs posted that are not in imminent danger, they should be in non-urgent and be notified on anyway.
No I totally agree. Dogs in imminent danger should be in Urgent. Those are the dogs me and friends are looking for to cross post. And non-urgent should be for dogs still needing help only. Thats all I'm saying. Its hard to weed through...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
24,301 Posts
What are you weeding through then?

If a dog is posted in Urgent rescue and is rescued, notify and they get moved (with the redirect to where they were moved and reason is in (__) in the subject line).

If a dog is posted in Urgent rescue and should be in non-urgent (Craig's List dogs, dogs in no-kill shelter, at someone's house), notify and they will be moved there.

Is it improperly listed dogs or the redirects? Did you look at those in the General Information area to see what I mean? They are also pretty easy to distinguish, because there is an arrow and I think they are in italics. ETA, nope, it says MOVED.

Just let me know - trying to make it user friendly.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,594 Posts
Discussion Starter #5
I appreciate your replies. I'll try to present my comments in another way that makes more sense. I have to go now but I'll be back.

Thanks again.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,594 Posts
Discussion Starter #7
I think you are seeing/not liking the redirects that are there so that people looking for the thread for a while can still find it. You can probably see redirects in the General Information forum as an example. Right. My fear is that like when doing searches using google etc. people generally look at only the first or second pages. So I'd like to see as many of the Urgent dogs on the first and second pages instead of the "moved" dogs taking up space. But maybe thats not a concern on forums like this like it is with search engines.

We can make it so that there are no redirects to another forum (follow up, rescue stories if dogs are adopted or PTS, non-urgent if going to a known rescue) but then people might not be able to find a thread they are looking for in the week or two that people are generally thinking of it. So that is something to discuss/think about. Thats a good point. If people come back to check status on an Urgent dog and don't see them anymore at all they might not think to look at "Where are they Now" or "Follow Up..." or "Non-Urgent."

I am going to move this thread without a redirect so that you can look at the Suggestion/Comment box and then find it. So that you can see what I mean. This isn't a big deal when it shows up on active topics, or is a topic you posted to, but when it is one you are following but haven't checked on for a while, it can be harder to locate. Yes, I see what you mean. So go check out the Suggestion/Comment box, then look at somewhere like General Info - yours is totally gone, poof, there are all sorts of arrows in General Info. And that's what you see in the rescue section - thread name and redirect.

Dogs not adopted or PTS that are in Urgent are dogs that are going to be PTS - in imminent danger - so we should not move them. If there are dogs posted that are not in imminent danger, they should be in non-urgent and be notified on anyway. Right. I was just thinking from my perspective of someone looking specifically for dogs in Urgent [imminent danger] to share and then second priority going into Non-Urgent [also or still need attention]. Like 2 clean lists for sharing and bumping purposes. But I was not thinking of it from all of the people who are tracking them. Especially people who are actively involved with contacting rescues and trying to coordinate transportation
Thanks a lot for taking the time to talk this out. I'm thinking that maybe my suggestions aren't a good idea afterall :)
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
27,461 Posts
I appreciate your replies. I'll try to present my comments in another way that makes more sense. I have to go now but I'll be back.

Thanks again.
I love that you are trying to help these dogs! :wub:

I know some of the problems I see are when dogs ARE rescued or homed, people add a post at the end of the thread but then FAIL TO DO A MODERATOR NOTIFY so we don't move it into the Follow Up section. The goal IS to unclutter the Urgent as needed so the dogs that still need help will rise to the top and be highlighted.

Hopefully people will be more aware now and not just add a final 'dog not listed' or 'dog in rescue' but ALSO do the Moderator Notification so we can move it.

:)
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
27,461 Posts
Sorry to be off topic, but it would sure be nice to have something for GSD mixes.
You are 100% correct and it's called petfinder.

This has been discussed many times in the past and the decision was made to have this be a place to highlight and let the GSD's in shelters/rescues shine in a place of their own.

There are many other wonderful forums and rescue boards that do a great job with the mixes.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
3,612 Posts
You are 100% correct and it's called petfinder.

This has been discussed many times in the past and the decision was made to have this be a place to highlight and let the GSD's in shelters/rescues shine in a place of their own.

There are many other wonderful forums and rescue boards that do a great job with the mixes.
I do wish that were true. Petfinder hasn't been a good resource. It tends to attract many foreign scams. I tried it twice and did not receive a legitimate response. Not one.

Rescues rarely call you/email you back. Just is what it is. I know, I've tried. They have their hands full with the purebreds.

I don't fault the board for this decision, but the real truth is, there are not many options at all for the mixes.

Only that it would be nice that a rescue forum was titled "GSD mixes."

Again, it's ok. My GSD mix is staying, but prior to me deciding that, I longed to be able to list him on a GSD mix forum on a board such as this, that gets a lot of traffic and so many know one another. I find it unfortunate that I cannot do that.
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
27,461 Posts
Again, it's ok. My GSD mix is staying, but prior to me deciding that, I longed to be able to list him on a GSD mix forum on a board such as this, that gets a lot of traffic and so many know one another. I find it unfortunate that I cannot do that.
We love mixes here and they can be highlighted and bragged about galore!

The ONLY place we are strict about the being GSD (and we don't demand papers, just the 'look' ) is on our rescue site.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,272 Posts
I would also urge the board to reconsider the "purebred only" requirement. As many members here actually have mixes it seems discordant with the spirit of the rest of the forum.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,272 Posts
I also personally believe the "purebred only" requirement lends itself to an anti-rescue feel that others have noted about this forum. I say this because it is a rare case that one can "prove" that a rescue dog is purebred.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,594 Posts
Discussion Starter #15 (Edited)
I love that you are trying to help these dogs! :wub:

I know some of the problems I see are when dogs ARE rescued or homed, people add a post at the end of the thread but then FAIL TO DO A MODERATOR NOTIFY so we don't move it into the Follow Up section. The goal IS to unclutter the Urgent as needed so the dogs that still need help will rise to the top and be highlighted.

Hopefully people will be more aware now and not just add a final 'dog not listed' or 'dog in rescue' but ALSO do the Moderator Notification so we can move it.

:)

I'm thinking the OP's probably multi-post and don't think to go back to each post and follow up.

And the rest of us see the message "This is ONLY to be used to report spam, advertising messages, and problematic (harassment, fighting, or rude) posts." when we alert Mod's to move Urgents. Mixed messages.
 
1 - 15 of 15 Posts
Top