German Shepherds Forum banner

1 - 17 of 17 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
152 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
He will pee outside and poop outside and then come in and pee and poop in the house. He already knows its wrong because when he does it he slinks off to a corner and looks at me with that just ate the neighbors cat look on his face.

This morning he started to poop in the house, I yelled and he stopped and I took him outside for the better part of 30 minutes and he did NOTHING. Then we went in and he pooped on the floor and ate it before I could stop him. We plan to give him some pineapple to curb the poop eating but the question now is, What to do what to do what to do
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
27,218 Posts
Keep him in his crate and take him directly outside in the same place everytime. Use a key word to tell him to go, stay with him. Tie his leash to you if he is not crated. Remember that he is still very young, and it may take time to teach him. When you catch him, say sternly "outside" and take him right out.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
24,301 Posts
He's not stubborn, he's just not sure how everything works including getting the feeling of having to go = getting outside. If you think about how long it takes to potty train a human (especially [generally] a boy) you will definitely rethink the stubborn.
It's a complicated process involving brain, GI tract, communication between species. I am amazed we can do it at all!

I think others will come on with concrete information on how best to do the actual thing (think bell, staying out after potties, giving it a name, schedule, leashing, rugs=grass) but I just wanted to say he's doing great so far.
 

·
Administrator & Alpha Bitch of the Wild Bunch
Joined
·
13,571 Posts
Originally Posted By: Bailey's Dad He already knows its wrong because when he does it he slinks off to a corner and looks at me with that just ate the neighbors cat look on his face.
No, he doesn't know it's wrong. Dogs don't think that way. He's slinking off into a corner because he's reading your emotions and reacting to them. He doesn't associate it with what he did.

How old is this pup?

Not only do puppies pee and poop frequently, but it's also not unusual at all for puppies to need to pee and poop multiple times in one setting. Just because he does each once when he's outside doesn't mean he's done, and he may need more time outside before coming back in.

Is he on a strict feeding and potty schedule? That will help tremendously.

If he does have an accident indoors, make sure to use an enzymatic cleaner like Nature's Miracle or Simple Solution to thoroughly clean the area. Regular household cleaners may seem to remove it, but they leave residual scent behind. You may not be able to still smell pee/poop there, but dog's can. Dogs are very scent oriented when it comes to relieving themselves and if they smell that they've peed/pooped somewhere before they are more likely to return to that spot to do it again, and smelling it will also trigger a response to pee or poop. So you need to make sure any possible pee/poop smell is removed from the house so he can't smell it.

Dogs are creatures of habit. Everytime he potty's in the house he's learning that it's ok to potty in the house. Correcting him for doing so isn't the answer, as many dogs will simply learn that they shouldn't pee/poop in your presence, not that they shouldn't do it in the house. So they may just learn to sneak off to a corner where you can't see them to pee/poope, and they may become less likely to potty outside when you're with them because they fear corrections from doing it in your presence.

You need to be proactive and prevent him from doing it altogether, not just wait to correct him when he does. Make sure he's on a schedule and take him out frequently, making sure to give him plenty of time to pee or poop multiple times if he needs to. Never let him out of your sight when in the house. Use doors/babygates or a leash tied to your beltloop to keep him nearby at all times. And watch him. Any sniffing the ground or circling indicates he's getting ready to potty, so get him outside quick. And make sure to praise him lavishly everytime he potty's outside. When you can't keep one eye glued to the pup at all times, he should be in a crate where he can't get into trouble and where natural instinct will tell him not to pee or poop.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
189 Posts
My Pitt Bull rescue was really hard to train but the vet told me something that worked quickly. She told me to take a really yummy treat outside with me (I used Pupperoni) and give it to her the minute she did her business. She said if you wait until they come back inside to reward them they may have already forgotten what they did right.

I fought with this dog for a few months on training until I used this method. She got it in less than a week using this suggestion.

We did keep her crated in between going outside.

Good luck!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
641 Posts
Originally Posted By: JeanKBBMMMAANHe's not stubborn, he's just not sure how everything works including getting the feeling of having to go = getting outside. If you think about how long it takes to potty train a human (especially [generally] a boy) you will definitely rethink the stubborn.
It's a complicated process involving brain, GI tract, communication between species. I am amazed we can do it at all!

I think others will come on with concrete information on how best to do the actual thing (think bell, staying out after potties, giving it a name, schedule, leashing, rugs=grass) but I just wanted to say he's doing great so far.
Hit the nail on the head! Great advice!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
915 Posts
All the things mentioned above worked for me. Bella is 6 months old now and I still keep an eye on her just to be sure...shes got it down pretty good but she wont bark or anything to go out. She will, however, sit at the door. I just have to be there to see her waiting. I used the treat trick and it worked great. I still treat her when she potties but not everytime. Its very sporadic but I keep at it to reinforce that shes doing a good thing.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
45 Posts
The age thing. Maybe is 12 weeks and she just started getting the 'clean' word. I can go outside, say 'clean' and see pees. More clean, and she poops!

Take a bit getting used to it, but what all pp said.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,311 Posts
Quote:
Quote:Originally Posted By: Bailey's Dad:
He already knows its wrong because when he does it he slinks off to a corner and looks at me with that just ate the neighbors cat look on his face.

No, he doesn't know it's wrong. Dogs don't think that way. He's slinking off into a corner because he's reading your emotions and reacting to them. He doesn't associate it with what he did.
Exactly.

I also agree with everything Chris said. Corrections don't serve any purpose until the dog knows what it's doing wrong, which isn't the case now. Just make sure you reward him like crazy every single time he pees or poops outside, get him on a regular feeding schedule, and give him plenty of time outside to use the bathroom as much as he needs to.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
74 Posts
Originally Posted By: JenniferHAll the things mentioned above worked for me. Bella is 6 months old now and I still keep an eye on her just to be sure...shes got it down pretty good but she wont bark or anything to go out. She will, however, sit at the door. I just have to be there to see her waiting. I used the treat trick and it worked great. I still treat her when she potties but not everytime. Its very sporadic but I keep at it to reinforce that shes doing a good thing.
My pup does that too, he just sits at the door so I have to watch him. he is just now 4 months. he has Never poo'd in the house once. He still sometimes pees on the floor by the door if he has been holding it for a long time (usually in the morning) and i dont let him out quick enough.

I gave him treats for about a week straight every time he went outside and I think he knows now.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
964 Posts
I thought Cooper was getting the hang of it and he did number 2 in the house. I see that it was my fault because I know he goes right away in the morning, and then 3 hrs or so after eating. It was my fault for starting lunch before I got him to poo after breakfast.

Cooper ate his poo when he first got here but has stoped although I still try and pick it up immediately. Funny he was only interested in HIS bm not the other dogs. Hmm.

Hang in there I have been at it longer than you. It is hard not to be impatient. My boxer got it so quickly but maybe females are easier.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2 Posts
OK - help me out...I appreciate everything you are saying, but as a mom, I am having trouble with a few things.....

First, how much water should we be giving Bailey? I give him about 1 cup, 3 times a day and I honestly don't think that is enough, but the more he gets, the more he pees.

Second, I have a hard time with leaving him crated so much. He dad tells me it is fine, but I think he needs interaction with us. Am I wrong?

HELP!!!!!!!!
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
21,368 Posts
I have never restricted water but that's just me :))

I also had the luxury of being home most of the time when I've had a puppy.

Housebreaking my males , for me, was much easier than my females. They go out ALOT, as in every couple of hours (if you have that being home luxury!) and as soon as puppy potties outside, I always made a HUGE deal out of it :)) They also were out immediately after waking up, coming out of the crate, eating.

Accidents inside are ignored, and puppy is scooped up and taken outside immediately..Inside accidents are MY fault for not being "on top" of a puppy who doesn't yet "get" outside pottying.

I did not crate my puppies alot, if I'm home and I can supervise, they are out interacting.

I think being consistent, taking him out OFTEN, really PRAISING him for pottying outside (even reward with a treat or toy!) he'll eventually "get" the outside potty thing. Just takes time :))

Just my 2 cents
Diane
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
964 Posts
I also hate the idea of restricting water. It is so important. I even let him have it in the crate at night. That said he is almost 14 weeks and still goes out in the niddle of the night. Usually around 4. He goes straight back to his crate and I fall back to sleep easily so it isn't a big deal to me. I KNOW if he didn't drink so much I would be better off but if he needs water I want him to have it. Food I do monitor. IAnd I have noticed 3-4 hrs after eating I should be expecting a BM. He pess every 2 hrs during the day. Maybe less but it feels more.

I only crate at night and 2 hrs in the afternoon but I work from home.
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
16,941 Posts
Hi Bailey's Mom and Dad,

I remembered this from another earlier post:

Originally Posted By: Bailey's Dad .
Bailey whines when he has to pee or poop and he pee'd on the wee wee pad when put on it
I'm no expert in house-breaking (haven't had to deal with that yet), but I'm curious, did the breeder you got Baley from train the puppies to use a pad? If that is the case, then not only do you have to train him to go outside, but also to "untrain" him from going inside. Wee wee pad on the floor in the house, carpet, flooring, probably all the same in his little mind. So it might take a bit longer with a few more setbacks than you might excpect to house-break Baily, but no doubt he will catch on and get it.

Just patience, consistency, carpet cleaner
will do the trick. A little puppy this age can not do "wrong", they don't have those moral understandings. Good habits need to be shaped and takes time.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
501 Posts
we never had a problem with beamer pooping & peeing in the house, but we do give her a treat & are like "YAYYY BEAMERR!" when she comes inside, but yeah the first couple weeks we had her she would go outside & do nothing, but inside she held it in. so we were going outside like every twenty minutes. just remember to take her out right after she eats.
 
1 - 17 of 17 Posts
Top