Welcome. I feed raw, and would encourage you to check out the raw section and see what you think. If you are set on feeding kibble (which there's nothing wrong with especially since you are doing the research to find a high quality holistic kibble) both of the ones you mention are not bad, but I would suggest to check a few others out. I know that Eagle Pack makes a good product, but I really shy away from corn completely and I know that corn is an ingredient there. I'm not 100% sure on Nutro, but I think they use corn too. I would suggest something grain free like Innova EVO, or a few other grain free foods.