German Shepherds Forum banner

1 - 11 of 11 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
145 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Hello guys,

Saturday I am planning to go with a friend who has a 20 months intact male. Mine is 15 months.

The dogs have not met but me and my friend went out already with Rex on a desert area here with trees and some hills. There will be no other distractions. He says his dog is super friendly with the same demeanor as Rex. My friend had GSDs before and he is an experienced dog owner. So I think his judgement can be trusted.

The plan is to go the two of us and our dogs on the same place and walk and play. My brother is telling me a male male that are intact is not a good idea....He also has dogs before but not a lot of experience.

Is this a good idea or a no no in all cases? If it is okay, any suggestions on how to go about this?

Many thanks

Mozi
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
466 Posts
Definitely depends on the dog. My boy Steel's sire isn't too fond of other intact males, but as long as they aren't in his face, he tolerates them. The two you and your friend have may be young enough to not have to worry, but again, depends on the dog. I'll leave introduction advice to the experts. I would just watch body language when they first meet, preferably not in one of their "territories."
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,252 Posts
Yes, it's really hard to predict how they'll get along. My male was fine at the dog park, playing with other males, some of which were intact. I took him there both before and after he was neutered.

Then, one day we met up with an intact mastiff. I could tell right away from this dog's body language that he was Trouble. His owner was aware, too, and we kept the two dogs as far apart as we could.

Unfortunately, we let our guard slip as we were leaving the park. We were able to get the dogs separated before they hurt each other, but the mastiff's owner suffered a nasty bite to her calf.

Just be careful, watch the body language, and be prepared to intervene if things start to go south. As a safety precaution, you might want to leave the leashes on the dogs when they are playing, or have them on long lines/lunge lines so you have something to grab to separate them. NEVER grab a fighting dog by the collar. That will almost guarantee a bite.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,861 Posts
Start walking them on leash and out of reach of each other to see their body language. Reward them for good behavior in each others presence. Take your time before ever letting them off leash. It can go both ways. Have a plan to separate them for when there is trouble.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
381 Posts
I wouldn't do it. I've seen dog fights and they are ugly. Thing is, dogs are fine until they aren't... and sometimes, if you don't have a lot of experience, you won't see the body language before it starts.

Breaking up a serious dog fight is like sticking your hand in a blender. You might be OK but most likely you'll come away with some serious injuries.

If you do this, carry a bite stick and know how to use it. A dog in a real fight will clamp on and be hard to release.

Intro on leash is a good idea, at first, but they might decide they are blood enemies an hour into the walk. Or might be playing nicely until something happens and one dog takes offense and goes overboard and a fight breaks out.

Two intact males can be fine, but in the real world, would be fighting for females and territory just about at this age.

Sometimes adolescent boys are ruled by only one body part and the brain control goes missing for a while.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
145 Posts
Discussion Starter #7
Mmmmmm. Making me worried....I thought that because they were in open field and only both of them, that it would be fine.....:(
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
855 Posts
Mmmmmm. Making me worried....I thought that because they were in open field and only both of them, that it would be fine.....:(

JMO but if your friend knows his dog like you say and his dog has been around intact males before with no issues and you should know your own dog--has your dog been around intact males before if so how did he act ??--frankly if you don't know what's meant when folks here say "body language" and how to read it--should anything begin to develop you won't recognize it--hopefully your experienced friend knows what he's looking at.....frankly I'm more concerned about you being worried--anxious and fearful of what to expect...I've said it before and so have other forum members....your dog WILL know (they CAN read body language of both dogs and humans) and more than likely react accordingly- by defending you.


I've done what you're asking about many times over the years--as long as I know the other owner and that his dog is not "dog aggressive"---unless a third party is planning on bringing a female who's in heat I wouldn't expect any problems...but again if you can't get by the worry and fear in your own head about this meeting...which your dog will surely pick up on...than my advice is... don't do it
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
239 Posts
Just my take from a beginner's point of view...

It seems like a worthy outing to try. How will you learn if your dog is ok with stuff like this if he's never exposed to it? Best to do it with a trusted dog and handler like your friend. Also gives you more experience at reading their body language. Just mitigate the risks. Don't commit to some long road-trip type outing where you won't feel easy about packing it in and going home if things don't go well....just keep it simple and relatively close to home, easy to get in and out of. Also, give yourself lots of room to walk "together" but "separate" at the same time. If the dogs don't seem to want to get along, but are ok being near each other, then you can still get a good walk out of it, and give your dog a chance to learn that other dogs aren't a threat.

That's how I'd look at it, if it were my outing. :)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,829 Posts
With every thing else that was said, how is the recall with both dogs? Have both been thoroughly recall proofed around other dogs? If so and if you and your friend understand their language, when it's time to leash up, I would put a little distance between you and your friend before calling as it will keep clear that play time is over and attention needs to,be focused on their humans. It will probably help with the transition and any opposition to being leashed.. This is just my thoughts.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
145 Posts
Discussion Starter #11
Ok great, for the all round suggestions.

To answer a few questions:

I have been reading lots on body language and always watchful for how when Rex interacts when on walks and others with him in terms of body language. I am no expert :) but I think I am good at reading if I keep close attention.

Yes, Rex has been playing with other dogs. A couple of times in a the dog park (which I stopped doing after knowing better) and one time at a beach where dogs are allowed. Those were off leash. Also he interacts well with all the neighbours dogs that are on leash and us on leash. He never lunged or been aggressive.

My friend tells me his dog is of the same exact temperament. So I think the "base" is good for a try as some suggest.

I am not the worrying type so if I decide to do it, I will go all in with confidence that all will be ok and Rex hopefully will pick up on that. When I mentioned worried, I meant reading some of the comments.

Recall is good but not tried and tested under all distractions. We will practice that a bit when there. However the area is safe.

I think overall, it is a good time to try this experience.

I will do it and report back!

Cheers
 
1 - 11 of 11 Posts
Top