German Shepherds Forum banner

1 - 20 of 70 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
31,874 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Within the last month, we had a couple of people who had never had litters and were asking advice.

Most of the advice was very helpful.

I am concerned that sometimes people give advice here that is taken, but the advice is not from people who have ever whelped or raised a litter or kept a pregnant bitch.

Specifically, I am talking about switching foods to something better or to grain free. But there are other things as well that someone who has never had a litter, may be very well-meaning, but may give advice that could actually be dangerous.

I do not know if we should be a little more clear in general that we are not vets, and that ultimately people need to weigh the advice with the understanding that not everyone giving the advice is considering all the information in light of all of the circumstances. Or should we try to qualify our posts to specifically say that we have never raised a litter, but...., or, "what I do when I have a litter is...."
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,452 Posts
This will always be a problem via internet...source of information and reliability. I understand your concerns Selzer, just not sure what can be done.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
24,301 Posts
I agree. I think qualifying the posts, and having you all (people who have raised a litter be it breeder or rescue person) asking people who have not, nicely of course, :) what is the basis for that information, and letting the OP know that always, always, always they should take this information and review it in partnership with their vet.

Some very dangerous things can happen when people take this as a replacement for vetting, and they should be using this information in conjunction with a great relationship with their DVM.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,991 Posts
The flip side of that is that just because someone breeds a dog, or even multiple dogs, it doesn't make them an expert on dog care, whelping, or raising litters.

The big breeders with tons of experience and people here who can actually vouch for their experience, knowledge, and quality (such as Chris Wild, for example) are people I would personally seek out if I had breeding questions. However, as I'm not a breeder it's only been this once that I've had to seek out that kind of advice (for a litter I'm fostering). Those that breed multiple litters on a regular basis, but don't ever seem to have anyone here that knows them or can vouch for them raise red flags in my mind.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
31,874 Posts
Discussion Starter #5
Rerun, that is an intersesting point.

Though I know there are several breeders on this site, the only one that I recongnize other people on the site having her dogs are the wildhaus kennel name in the signatures.

Only one or two of my buyers have ever registered.

I would imagine that it might be that some of the people are members already when they purchase their dogs from Chris.

But not everyone who owns a GSD is spending hours and hours on an internet site for GSDs.

I guess I am not here (on this site) to look for puppy buyers. And I am not actively encouraging puppy buyers to find this site or join it. I imagine that for other breeders it is similar. I am much more interested in getting them into puppy classes, and basic obedience.

It does not raise red flags for me. And, you have to be around long enough to notice that people have Wildhaus names in their signatures. These people need information right now. They got puppies coming right now. While everyone who has successfully raised a litter or many litters, may not be an expert, I would certainly take their advice over someone who has a dog and has discovered that their dog does better on a grain free food, or someone who has heard of someone with a similar issue, etc.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
27,228 Posts
Selzer, I took Reruns comments to mean;

breeders who post on this site and won't show their real names, or post their kennels, yet say they are "breeders".
I am aware not many have websites but there are some who say they are breeders and according to their comments, have been doing it forever, yet won't let the public know who they really are?
I would think if they are proud of what they are producing, they wouldn't try to be so secretive about their program. Transparency in rescue is a given, or there is little trust the rescue, it works that way for breeders as well.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,297 Posts
I'm not a breeder, never will be. I don't know anything about it, it seems like a lot involved.

I was wondering, in the breeder section, is there a bullet point suggestion list for ppl that are having litters, some oops or otherwise? A quick reference for ppl to look at and learn quick?

I know you all aren't vets, but I would hope that if someone was really interested or invested in the litter to be born on already dropped, they'd have somewhere to go w/o all the ... you are an irresponsible person stuff that goes along w/ a post about asking for advice.

If there is already a thread like that.. they perhaps we can just start pointing them too it. ??

Just a suggestion.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,725 Posts
You are making assumptions that they are not proud of what they do...you don't know that. They may even be better breeders than Chris Wild or who knows they may not be When people post questions on the internet they have to realize that they can get a response from anyone. If you are breeding then I would think that if you don't have experience you would find someone in real life that could help you People have a right to post...people who are asking the questions need to figure out what makes the most sense
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,067 Posts
I get over a thousand hits a month on my web-site. It is not listed in this forum for very specific reasons but somebody is finding it. Some breeders are just that - breeders. They breed - they don't always show or title their dogs. They spend their time finding the best bloodlines and genetics to use in their breeding program.

Web-site or not, titles or not, the only real way to know a breeder and their dogs is to visit them. I'm from the old school, where breeders talk you to death about their breeding program and tell you anything you want to know if you are interested in getting a pup.

Long before internet, word of mouth and referals from satisfied customers kept many breeders afloat.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
27,228 Posts
You are making assumptions that they are not proud of what they do...you don't know that. When people post questions on the internet they have to realize that they can get a response from anyone. If you are breeding then I would think that if you don't have experience you would find someone in real life that could help you People have a right to post...people who are asking the questions need to figure out what makes the most sense
I agree with what you say, and want to make a point of what I meant in my post~ the breeders who don't go by their real names... So we don't know who they really are, by their choice. Why not be transparent?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,725 Posts
Why does it bother you so much...maybe they don't need the internet to sell their dogs..Personally I would hate to be talked to death...been there done that
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
27,228 Posts
Holland, if your post #11 was addressing mine(#6 &10), this is what I was responding to~ has nothing to do with the internet but this site and this post only:
rerun said:
Those that breed multiple litters on a regular basis, but don't ever seem to have anyone here that knows them or can vouch for them raise red flags in my mind.
It doesn't "bother" me at all.
One thing that Does "bother" me is how there is no reply box any longer, never know who is replying to who unless we take up space by using the quote box constantly! :)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
27,228 Posts
It is the format of the server...nothing can be done because it is vbulletin.
I thought Shepherds was a he...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,067 Posts
I agree with what you say, and want to make a point of what I meant in my post~ the breeders who don't go by their real names... So we don't know who they really are, by their choice. Why not be transparent?
All my friends call me Doc. It is a titled I earned and a nick name - people in here call me all sorts of names :D.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
27,228 Posts
Hi Lewie! :eek:
 

·
"I like Daffy" Moderator
Joined
·
3,276 Posts
Maybe he's Huey or Dewie!:whistle:
 
1 - 20 of 70 Posts
Top