<span style="color: #000099">You have lots of great questions and you have come to a great place for answers. </span>
Originally Posted By: LiamGSDI have a new German Shepherd puppy, brought back from a very trusting and knowledgeable breeder in Poland. He is from German lines (champ) and I am having so much trouble with the little <span style="color: #33FF33">monster</span>!
<span style="color: #000099">It sounds like he may be from working lines and needs a job to do. Sessions with trainers can be from $80.00 an hour to $150.00 and hour in our area...probably more for long term training. The one that I went to was $2000.00 for long term training for basic obedience. Basic Puppy Training with someone reputable would be of GREAT HELP to both you and your puppy and do it SOON</span>
His name is Liam. Now, the problem is mainly that he bites and bites and bites like there's no tomorrow! He's getting bigger by the days now and it is really starting to hurt. This mostly happens when we are playing or when he is in his "hyper" mode. I try to give him a whimper or a stern NO with immediate ignorance afterwords, but he just does not care. I can't allow him to play with my younger brothers because he will be able to hurt them. Once he gets a grip on my arm, he starts pulling and I can only make him let go by grabbing the scruff of his neck.
<span style="color: #000099">
A mother dog teaches her pups by 'scruffing' them. It works well when the pups are young but can be less effective as they get older. How old is your pup?</span>
Let's put it this way, he is <u>too intelligent</u> for his own good. It's not that he doesn't know he is doing wrong, because if I have a treat at hand he will do ANYTHING for it without hesitation. He knows how to sit, down, paw, wait, drop it, and leave it if he knows I have a treat. Without treats, I'm useless.
<span style="color: #000099">Don't give up and feel useless. Puppies are a lot of work, but SO rewarding. I think that all of us here find out German Shepherds too intelligent That's what German Shepherds are. You need to be committed to this dog for a long time and it's up to you to learn how to be a team and not let the dog be in charge of the team rules</span>
Should I drop the treats all together and start off from a clean page with JUST physical praise? I just need some answers on this.
<span style="color: #000099">There's a lot of controversy about treat training. Personally, I am in favor of it if it works. He is still pretty young; you want to build consistent behavior in him. You can decrease the frequency of the treats as the behaviors that you want become stronger.</span>
It's not that he's aggressive, not at all, although he does get a little snappy when I correct him.
Liam is an angel when he is not in a playful mood, he loves to come by and rest his little head on my lap and I can <u>playful</u> tease him then without him even trying to bite back.
Thanks to anyone who takes the time to read this and helps me out. Are all German Shepherd puppies like this? Please tell me your experiences raising and training a German Shepherd pup!
<span style="color: #000099">
I believe that most German Shepherd puppies are like this; and a lot of them remain strong willed and too intelligent as they grow into dogs. You have to be strong willed and more intelligent. They are a working breed and need a job to do. You need to find something that you can work at together; walk, run, find weeds, balls, squirrels.</span>
By the way, is obedience training worth it? I just can't afford to spend so much money on something that I am not sure will help. About how much will it cost?
It depends on the trainer and what kind of training that you are looking for. At the very least, find a puppy class; it will teach you and your puppy how to work as a team. And do it SOON. Your puppy is being a puppy now. You need to learn how to teach him what is appropriate behavior and what is not.
There are also a lot of books out there, depending on what kind of training that you become comfortable with. Patricia B. McConnell has some good books, as does<span style="color: #FF0000"> Suzanne Clothier
</span>. They are more 'relationship based training' which is okay if you're training a companion dog, but probably insufficient if you want to do Schutzhund or Agility or anything competitive...but a good place to start. Control Unleashed by Leslie McDermott has a lot of good training techniques.
Your pup still sounds really young; any kind of <span style="color: #FF0000">training
</span> will be worth it if you research and find something good. You can probably find someone on this board who is in your area that can give you some advice.