I keep it simple and use my pup's regular kibble as treats; each morning I put a handful (and I do try to roughly count that as part of the daily amount) of kibble in my jeans pocket. Oh heck, every pocket of anything I wear has kibble in it, always have to clean it out before putting anything in washer!) I guess the biggest reason I do this is that I had a long problem on prior dog with SIBO, and when at last her diet/med regimen got her in control, hated to deprive her of treats, so kept kibble in my pocket for that beloved dog. And...this pupster has from Day One had a tendency for soft stools in the evening, which I now have under good control, and thus also just the kibble....don't want to go upsetting the boat. Plus I know the kibble is healthy vs junk, and she is simply eager to get her pieces of it, so we're both happy!