Don't know about the two you mentioned, but my 9 week-old pup loves Full Moon Duck-flavored Training Treats. They look like tiny little sausage bits and admittedly smell delicious... he seems to love them but only gets them as a high-value treat when he does something really awesome. He also enjoys Cloud Star's Tricky Trainers Cheddar Flavor, which smell like mac n' cheese. Not sure why all of his favorite treats smell yummy to me.
Other than that, we give him kibble (Orijen Large Breed Puppy) as quick treats and he enjoys that also.
Last edited by Storms; 09-05-2018 at 11:06 AM.