Theres so many different types of trainers out there. I feel like behavorist's prescribe meds where as a behavior modification trainer, gets to the root of the problem and changes the state of mind of the dog, fixing whatever issue there is.
The problem is, some people don't want to bring their dog to a trainer that can introduce the word 'no' and the concept of 'you are responsible for your actions, and the bad decisions you make have consequence'. So instead people bring their dog to a 'behaviorist' and get prescribed meds to "fix" (mask) the problem.
I know if my dog had behavior issues I sure as **** wouldn't be bringing them to a positive only (no such thing) trainer.
After three private lessons, a behaviorist said I should take my dog to Schutzhund since they knew how to deal with GSDs. Read that as in: he was a handful for the behaviorist.
You need to define what you mean by "behaviorist." It's an unregulated term. There's no nationally recognized credential like a CPDT, so idiots and charlatans abound.
When I use the term "behaviorist," I think of a board-certified veterinarian behaviorist. They can bring medical, neurological, hormonal, and other physical concerns into the evaluation of behavior. In addition to the DVM, they've done a residency in applied behavior and satisfied the demanding qualifications for board cert. There are only a few of them in the country. You can find them through the American College of Veterinary Behaviorists: ACVB
For standard misbehavior, you don't need one. For OCD and related issues, I would want to work with one -- research just came out showing canine autism exists (!!!). The OCD stuff we sometimes discuss here (tail chasing, etc.) has some documented links to explosive rage in the study, and there's no longer a doubt it's neurological, not just "learned behavior." The researchers found what was going on in the brains of dogs' suffering from some forms of OCD closely paralleled autism in human children's brains -- it's a revolutionary finding. Those dogs need meds, though they're barely at the beginning of figuring out what helps. This is a new frontier in veterinary medicine -- the field is in its infancy.
A trainer can teach you how to teach your dog commands. A behaviorist can fix problems created by the handler. A behaviorist is a trainer. A trainer may not understand behaviors or how to correct them (that person is not a good trainer, but a lot aren't very good).
I caught some of the Diane Reems show. Very interesting.
I was especially struck by something the vet said about what un-natural lives we are giving dogs these days. He said that a lot of the issues dogs have are because they are never allowed to be dogs. Fascinating show, I'll try to find time to listen to the whole thing.
The behaviorist a pup-buyer took a dog too sounded like a total hack. The "behaviorist" used a spray bottle to correct the then 11 month old dog for barking, or jumping, or running amok or whatever she didn't like. The dog grabbed the spray bottle and destroyed it. The "behaviorist" concluded that this dog was a genetic throwback to the its wolf ancestors and a lost cause. Happy to report I found an appropriate home for this very stable, social, loving, wonderful dog, and he is thriving.
I think behaviorists can be a big scam- I mean I understand dogs can have mental health issues but I think many are too quick to Dx a mental health problem. Exercise, training, and understanding of a dog's needs are generally the way to a good dog-human relationship.
The behaviorist a pup-buyer took a dog too sounded like a total hack. The "behaviorist" used a spray bottle to correct the then 11 month old dog for barking, or jumping, or running amok or whatever she didn't like. The dog grabbed the spray bottle and destroyed it. The "behaviorist" concluded that this dog was a genetic throwback to the its wolf ancestors and a lost cause.
I agree with the post by Magwart. My boy has fear aggression issues. I tried everything, we went through a myriad of professional trainers, classes, schutzhund traning, etc... the problem just got worse and worse. My Vet recommended a Veterinary Behaviorist. We were lucky because there are so few Certified American College of Veterinary Behaviorists around. After working with her, we have had nothing but results. He is no longer people reactive, his dog reactivity is improving. He is being taught how to cope with his fears not to just supress them. Only sound scientific proven methods are being used, to feel good hocus pocus.
I would not paint all "professional" trainers with the same brush, neither should we with Veterinary Behaviorists.
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
German Shepherds Forum
2.6M posts
121.9K members
Since 2002
A forum community dedicated to all German Shepherd owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about bloodlines, training, breeding, service dogs, and more!