|Topic Review (Newest First)|
|02-27-2014 06:12 PM|
No worries, no need to apologize.
My comments weren't directed at you but more in general and meant in the spirit of helping you understand the differences better.
German Shepherds, the most complicated breed in the world, I like to say.
Also regarding the showline more 'pet' vs 'working line' that's not going to be a pat straightforward answer either.
I have a WGSL and I can say, humbly**, that she would be too much dog for a lot of average pet owners. On the other side of the coin she would be a total marshmellow for some of the guys/gals who have worked with Police K9s, Military and the working line IPO dogs that our more experienced members would term as 'serious dogs capable of work'.
So it's on a continuum, depending on the dog and on the family/prospective owners. The best way for you to get a feel is to meet different dogs if you can. Look into IPO trials and shows in your area and meet with breeders and their dogs to help you get a better idea if possible.
(**humbly because I'm not a super duper trainer and have met working line dogs that would probably run me over....)
Originally Posted by twelvegates View Post
|02-27-2014 04:10 PM|
|twelvegates||Thank you. Sorry about the use of the term "roached". I understand the difference between sloped and roached.|
|02-27-2014 02:43 PM|
One more thread with some good pics and discussion about top lines in the GSD.
Hope this helps!
|02-27-2014 02:35 PM|
|02-27-2014 02:30 PM|
ugggh....I know I should just let it go...and maybe it's because I was into horses for so long and conformation is a huge deal the whole business about 'roach back' bugs me.
Most people don't know what a 'roach back' really is.
To the OP I wouldn't worry about 'roach' back as it's fairly rare.
*Most* of the non-straight back dogs are this way because of rear leg angulation not because the back itself has too much curve/slope.
I'll dig up some threads and link them in case you'd like to read up on it.
|02-27-2014 02:17 PM|
|twelvegates||Thank you. Is a show line dog more of a general pet sort of animal, as compared to a working dog?|
|02-27-2014 02:07 PM|
I'm in Colorado and I got my boy from Rocky Mountain German Shepherds. They primarily breed showline, but I think they are now delving into working lines as well.
My boy has a very straight back and is not roached. I have been very happy with the kennel and know several other people that have dogs from there and are very happy. With that being said, I don't believe they do DM testing but show all of their OFA ratings on their dogs. I would call several breeders in CO and ask them if they do DM testing on their dogs.
I personally think it best to visit first hand each facility and see the operations and dogs in person.
Good luck with your search!
|02-27-2014 01:09 PM|
Thanks for the input so far. Some of the shepherds in that video moved like my DM shepherd in the back end. Strange.
Anyone care to comment on what testing you want to see in the parents? Or is it just too much of a "crap shoot" to put much weight on that? I spoke with my vet on whether DM was absolutely ONLY a genetic issue in GSDs and she sort of looked at me sideways and said she wasn't convinced.
|02-27-2014 11:27 AM|
I'm in CO and don't know any breeders around here that I'd get a dog from. There might be good breeders here and I just haven't found them yet. A lot of the breeders I've found here have roached-back showline dogs, which I don't care for.
Regarding roaching and stacking, the roaching is their conformation. Yeah you can alter a dog's appearance with a stack, but there is only so much you can do. It would be extremely difficult (probably impossible) for me to stack my fairly-straight GSDs with such a roach as many show dogs have. A roach is not there only in the photo, as some people try to claim. Take this video for example. You can clearly see the dogs' roached toplines as they are moving.
If you don't want a dog with a roached back, don't get one from a breeder that has those dogs.
|02-27-2014 10:58 AM|
Sorry can't help with CO breeders but I can help with question #3, it's great that you are asking and not drawing conclusions off the bat.
First regarding top lines/backs there have been lots of discussions regarding what 'roach' back is vs 'straight' vs angled top lines. You can use the search function on the forum to look up the threads that go into this in detail.
Second, yes, how they are stacked can greatly affect the appearance of their top line in photos. Personally I don't like the way the GSD breed is stacked, it's too extreme IMHO.
Third, in general, a dogs top line does not affect whether it's likely to have health problems or genetic issues. Most importantly, you'll often hear and read on the net that 'straight backed working line dogs' do NOT get hip dysplasia. That is false, false and totally false.
All lines American Show, West German Show, Working lines and the subsets within can end up with hip dysplasia.
Your best bet is finding a good breeder that knows his/her lines and carefully breeds to avoid health issues through testing and tracking progeny from his/her breeding program, even that's not always a guarantee but you can certainly stack the odds in your favor.
Good luck with your puppy search.
Originally Posted by twelvegates View Post
|This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.|