German Shepherd Dog Forums - Reply to Topic

Increase font size: 0, 10, 25, 50% is the premier German Shepherd Forum on the internet. Registered Users do not see the above ads.
Thread: Breeding from my GSD? Help and advice. Reply to Thread
Send Trackbacks to (Separate multiple URLs with spaces):
Post Icons
You may choose an icon for your message from the following list:

Register Now

In order to be able to post messages on the German Shepherd Dog Forums forums, you must first register.
Please enter your desired user name, your email address and other required details in the form below.
User Name:
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.
Confirm Password:
Email Address
Please enter a valid email address for yourself.
Email Address:
Security Question
While balancing on a piece of wood, two inches by four inches known as a 2x4, john and his friend sally both spotted a dalmatian inside a truck with sirens, headed to put out a fire. State what the 2x4 is made of.


Human Verification

In order to verify that you are a human and not a spam bot, please enter the answer into the following box below based on the instructions contained in the graphic.

Additional Options
Miscellaneous Options

Topic Review (Newest First)
02-23-2014 11:12 PM
trudy no one mentioned this so I will, you are going to be visiting France while your girl friend works and so will be around all day, believe it or not but most rental places don't want a large litter of pups in their place..also will you have the large emergency fund available if anything goes wrong...Are you prepared for your girl to die?? raise pups by hand?? Why don't you arrange your time there as kennel help at a breeding kennel to learn the ins and outs, since you won't need a job you can do it free and really learn lots.

Also your dog's disposition will change, she is stilll a pup, She will come across situations and people/things to react to, reaction is not wrong but how long to recover?? I guarantee the dog between 9-20 months will not be the same at 30 months when temperment is set and adulthood ensues.. Then you will truly have an idea, she should in the mean time grow up and have lots of training, then good luck on health and temperament tests
02-23-2014 07:11 PM
DaniFani Wanted to add....most people in your position say how they would never let a pup go to a bad home, or that if someone didn't want it at 6 months/1 year/5 years/ that they'd take the pup back. The thing is, it's REALLY easy to say that now. There is a thread around here about a woman who bred her GSD. I think she had 10 or so puppies, had a heck of a time finding homes for all of them, had three returned at 6 months, took a LONG time to find them homes...because lets face it, a bouncing, no manners, crazy 6 month old puppy of any breed, seems overwhelming to the new home. Most want a little puppy anyways. She talked of how incredibly difficult it was, and how she wished she'd never have done it.

Another thread about a woman who lost the mother during labor and was left with 10 puppies. After three died, she finally had to surrender the rest to a shelter.

So....really think about this>>"I'd take a pup back." How would that go? With your wife and you traveling? With your current dogs? To add 1 or 2 six month old puppies to your lives for who-knows-how-long, until you can find a good home. Breeders are set up for this. They have kennels, land, and are ready for these "issues" that crop up. Are you?
02-23-2014 07:05 PM
Originally Posted by Welshy23 View Post
Thank you for your comments, its exactly what i wanted.

I have already enquired into the hip/elbow score with the vet, its 350ish for that. She is also KC registered and so would the puppies. A dime a dozen, yes... But i've been around many breeders around the UK and been vigorously checking adverts and unfortunately there is either 300 pound puppies from travelers or "back yard breeders" or perfect pedigree puppies which break the bank (for many people) at 800+. Now i paid alot for my puppy because i cared about her health and what the breeder i bought her from offered me and the puppies health and life. So dime a dozen is really subjective. Metaphorically I could go out and buy a BMW, yes dime a dozen but unless you know what you're doing and want, your always taking a risk of failure. Same with puppies in my opinion.

My breeder can inform me of who a suitable match, not only that i can personally search through close relatives to her family tree and pick a sire that is suitable. I understand this.

This is your opinion with what i want from a German Shepherd, i dont feel that my personal opinion and ideology is an issues with what i want the end result to be. I actually said in my post that it would not be considered until her third season. She hasn't even started her second. So she would not be 16 months when she would be pregnant.

Yes i completly agree with you about people ruining the breed through similar circumstance. But atleast i've come here with some knowledge and the confidence to ask for help. Surely this is what people like you would want. This happens all over the world regardless of your bluntness, would you rather it happen with your advice or without?.. No disrespect intended toward yourself. As for training, i work full time. Where do you think i am able to gain experience in whelping or dog breeding? Vet courses/uni in the uk take 6 plus years and wont hardly ever cover dog breeding! I dont have time to take work experience from a vet either... and like i stated in my original post if there's a course or valuable information i could benefit from please point it out. Yes it sound narrow minded but its the truth.

I did not make it clear but i would never breed from her if i did a hip score and it came out that she had biscuits for hips and would suffer HD sooner in life. Im a realist, i honestly want what i think is best, my personal opinion. Who is to tell me what i feel is wrong? There is no set agenda for the breed. If i want to concentrate on the temperament of the breed then i dont see a problem. Im not a stupid person, i dont need money, i love my dog, i love all animals. This is what i would call a passion, there are no laws preventing me from doing so and untill there is with the right guidance, training and circumstances i will attempt to breed from my dog which is safe for her.

I appreciate your honest reply and would like more advice from you regarding my reply to you!

Thanks for not taking my blunt post too personally. My current GSD is from Germany, he was around your price point of expensive. When shipping is taken into account, it's about the same I'd pay for a pup in the US. There is a reason those pups are that price range. It's noble, that you want to supply quality pups to the masses, however..."quality" is different for everyone. "Quality" to me, is a pup who's parents are temperament tested (I prefer IPO/SchH or dogs actively working the streets (successfully)). I prefer that because I am in the sport world, and want a dog I can compete well with in sport. Even if I wasn't in sport, I would still want the pup's parents (and dogs throughout it's pedigree) tested in some fashion, probably the same...because nerve is everything, and should be of the highest expecatation, even in a pet home.

I've had the nervy dog, it's exhausting and nowhere near as wonderful as a stable dog. I bought from a breeder who had a lot of the same mentalities as you...dogs were great in the few, sterile, environments the breeder presented to them. However, I took the offspring and exposed it to the very foundations of SchH and exposed what the breeder was turning a blind eye to because, "the parents are so good with other dogs and family members, and I want to provide 'quality pups' at an affordable cost."

The CGC is nice, but it doesn't truly expose BREED WORTHY nerves/thresholds/drives etc. Because my expectations are what they are, I understand that the breeder is going to be putting a lot of time, money, and energy, into that breeding stock. Training equipment, time, trial fees, time, energy, time, gas, time, get my point. I expect them to charge for all of that. I also know that *most of the quality breeders I will buy from, aren't making money at all off their dogs when all is said and done. I love the "I'm not in it for the money." Yeah, a lot aren't, yet they are still jumping through all the hoops to prove "quality."

Oh and as for this>>"There is no set agenda for the breed."

Well...that couldn't be further from the truth. There is a standard, there are supposed to be expectations and requirements. True, BY LAW there are no requirements to breed. By law, I can also buy a dog and dump it in a shelter after a year, and then buy another and do the law, I can do that as many times as I want....doesn't mean it's right, or that I should....Right now your expectations for the breed are dismal. A breed-able GSD should be able to stand up to pressure, to not shy away from a stick hit, on a sleeve, from the "bad guy," he/she should be able to track, she should be able to perform under threat/pressure...not show any avoidance/inappropriate aggression/fearful etc, should be able to counter the decoy/bad guy nicely...these things aren't shown in a CGC. They are exposed in the months/years of training the dog, in preparation for the title. It isn't the title itself that proves anything, but the training/exposures while getting there. Then you have to trust that the breeder is listening to the dog and it's capabilities....but that's another discussion.

I also agree wholeheartedly with everything said by Merciel.

M, you wouldn't happen to be in law, would you?? Because that was a brilliantly presented argument. ;-)
02-23-2014 06:31 PM
JakodaCD OA I am not a breeder (nor pretend to be but, something I would check out as well is, littermates. Because 'you' have a great girl, how are the other ones turning out?

I'd want to meet them in person if it was a viable option
02-23-2014 06:06 PM
Welshy23 This is exactly what i wanted it exp heads informing me of their personal opinions. It gives me new ways of looking at things and views i never looked at from certain angles.

For the titles etc i can see and agree it opens up the stud and the potential future puppy market ownership which is very important. I would never leave the pups go without insurance of 4 weeks and a clause to bring them back if the new owner cannot continuing owning them. I dont want to do things half assed and i hope i have made that clear through all of my posts.

In regards to what you've said i can see the clear and needed benefits of the title even if its just one. Now since i've posted this ive been in contact with someone who is in the business of dogs and trials regarding tracking trials etc. Since a pup shes always had a keep nose and i have taught her the basics of tracking a scent, which she also really enjoys.

I would never sell any puppies to families or people who i even believe to be shady or want the pups for negative reasons. Like i said, im not in this for monitory gain. I know full well this process is not cheap and stress free.
02-23-2014 05:59 PM
Shade I have to agree with a few posts here, it's not just for you that titles and health tests are done but for the stud owner as well as potential puppy owners. Those that would willing buy from a first time breeder without any titles and minimum health tests (hips are great but that's just a start) are rarely the type of people you want to give the puppies to. Educated and committed owners know what they're looking for and aren't willing to settle.

You want the best of the best, that takes effort on your part to attract them.
02-23-2014 05:49 PM
Originally Posted by Welshy23 View Post
Yes, this is also being looked at. Here in the UK, im not sure if you have similar type tests or if its the same but its called the good canine citizen test (or very similar). You get graded on the ability to listen, recall, behavior in public toward other dogs, walking on the lead... (being a good dog basically in all environments) Which she is more than capable and very very good at doing! And like i said already looking into/getting steps into.
We have the CGC here, too, but I meant an actual temperament test. CGC is a good start, but if you want to breed this dog I would go further with the TT and obedience titles.
02-23-2014 05:45 PM
Merciel My strong suggestion would be to back up a few steps and work on training/trialing your dog in some sport or working venue before thinking about breeding her.

If you bred that dog today, then like Dani said, that would be the essence of BYB: breeding a friendly family pet out of good intentions because "she's a nice dog and I love her."

Based on your post, I don't have any idea whether your dog is legitimately breedworthy. Maybe she is, maybe she isn't. I can't tell. But let's assume, for the sake of argument, that she is. Let's assume that she has strong genes, is a truly exceptional example of the breed, and should not be lost to the breed pool.

Okay. So the first concern is finding a good stud dog who complements your dog's genetic package. Most responsible owners of proven, tested, high-quality stud dogs will not breed their dog to somebody's untitled, untested family pet. That knocks out a huge percentage of your best matches. Your choices will be narrowed down to commercially motivated owners (who just want the stud fee and don't care if it's a good match or not) and clueless owners who either don't know or don't care enough to restrict their dog's breeding activities.

In either case, your chances of finding the right stud for your dog are decreased -- clueless owners generally aren't going to have access to good bloodlines, and commercial ones don't care whether their particular dog is a good match to yours, so even if they do have good bloodlines (and many don't), they may not match up well to your dog's side of the pedigree. So even if your dog is AWESOME, the odds that her awesomeness will go down to the puppies is substantially reduced, because you will probably be breeding her to a dog with inferior or incompatible genetics.

But let's say you get lucky and manage to score a great stud dog anyway. And you produce a litter of great puppies.

Where do those puppies go? Most owners who are serious about doing something with their dogs -- showing, competing, or working -- won't take puppies out of untitled and unproven parents, because they are typically looking for particular traits in their dogs. Most owners who are educated and concerned about responsible breeding practices won't take them for ethical reasons. So that leaves you with a significantly narrower range of homes that are less likely to be knowledgeable about or involved with the breed.

Let's assume, though, that you are able to successfully place all of your puppies in loving, caring homes where they are cherished as family pets. None of them has to go to a shelter and none of them winds up in a less-than-stellar living situation. They all get good homes.

How many of those good homes are going to breed them? Probably few to none, because most responsible owners have internalized that you do not breed your untitled, untested family pet. And if they did breed those puppies, then you would have to go all the way back up to the beginning of this post and consider the odds that they'd find decent, compatible studs, suitable homes for their own puppies, etc.

In all likelihood, within one or two generations, you would lose whatever traits made your original dog so special. And that's assuming the line didn't just end with the first generation because all of the puppy owners -- being responsible pet homes -- prevented their dogs from breeding.

IF your dog is truly something special, and IF she is a worthy addition to the breed, then the best way to ensure those genes stay in circulation is to elevate her to the upper echelon of breeding dogs and get her considered by other serious breeders. That means titling and health testing your dog, making connections in the breed world, and expanding your own base of knowledge so that you really can tell whether your dog is that unique after all.
02-23-2014 05:44 PM
Originally Posted by I_LOVE_MY_MIKKO View Post
A title is not just a personal accolade -it is something that objectively says that your dog can work, cope in a stressful environment around people, dogs, distractions, etc. It is easy to say how great your own dog is, but the training, working, titling, means that other people, strangers, are judging your dog's abilities.

If your focus is on temperament and a well-behaved dog, at least pass the temperament test and get some obedience titles (and of course all of the health tests).
Yes, this is also being looked at. Here in the UK, im not sure if you have similar type tests or if its the same but its called the good canine citizen test (or very similar). You get graded on the ability to listen, recall, behavior in public toward other dogs, walking on the lead... (being a good dog basically in all environments) Which she is more than capable and very very good at doing! And like i said already looking into/getting steps into.
02-23-2014 05:38 PM
Originally Posted by Welshy23 View Post
Not everyone want their dog to be a champion, sometimes, like myself personally are over the moon with my girl how she is. I dont need a ribbon or an accolade to tell me shes special. I dont need one for her pups to be worth more money either.

I want her to experience what would only happy naturally in the animal kingdom and also like i said in other posts pass on her valuable traits and qualities. I feel you didnt read all of my original post...
A title is not just a personal accolade -it is something that objectively says that your dog can work, cope in a stressful environment around people, dogs, distractions, etc. It is easy to say how great your own dog is, but the training, working, titling, means that other people, strangers, are judging your dog's abilities.

If your focus is on temperament and a well-behaved dog, at least pass the temperament test and get some obedience titles (and of course all of the health tests).
This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.

Posting Rules
You may post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 09:05 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2016, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SEO by vBSEO 3.3.2
Basset Hound Forum Doberman Forum Golden Retriever Forum Beagle Forum
Boxer Forum Dog Forum Pit Bull Forum Poodle Forum
Bulldog Forum Fish Forum Havanese Forum Maltese Forum
Cat Forum German Shepherd Forum Labradoodle Forum Yorkie Forum Hedgehog Forum
Chihuahua Forum Retriever Breeds Cichlid Forum Dart Frog Forum Mice Breeder Forum