|Topic Review (Newest First)|
|12-27-2012 04:55 PM|
|huntergreen||this thread shouldn't be this long. op, you are not knowledgeable or experienced enough to start a breeding program. sorry to be blunt but this is the way it is. if i was going to start a breeding program, and i am not, i would work for a respected breeder near me for a few years, make some contacts and then see what i would have to offer the breed.|
|12-27-2012 12:24 PM|
OP...the truth is, your dog came from someone like you, who purchased a GSD and at 6 months decided it was the greatest thing since sliced bread and that they would breed it. They just weren't "lucky" enough to stumble upon this forum, or accross people that are really involved in the dog world to rip them a new one. If you look up previous "I want to breed my dog" threads, you'll see that it happens so often that people just don't have the patience for it anymore.
The way I try to explain it to new members of my GSD club is that, when you ask someone about your dog, you will get the honest, objective, truth about your dog, with absolutely no sugar coating. They will tell you exactly how they feel about the color, structure, temperament, ect of your dog without any consideration that this is your beloved family pet. We all look at our dogs as family members, some of us as kids, but the dogs are still compared to one another more like property and not as gently as children would be.
Kudos to you for sticking around and learning/understanding why people are saying what they are. No one is judging you, or your dogs ability to be a great family pet, and its ability to love you and be everything you wish it to be, they are just judging it based on the fact that there might be one next door that has something better to offer the dog world as a whole. Once you think of the numbers, and how quickly a genetic line can spiral out of control, you'll understand. If an average litter is 6 puppies, and even 2 of those pups are being bred, in a very small amount of time you have almost exponential growth of a line that isn't proven, isn't exeplory, and might not even be to standard due to the lack of knowledge/experience on the owners/breeders part.
|12-25-2012 08:34 PM|
Carmen, my point is that a kennel can have generations of their stock and have good dogs....it goes without saying that you need a plan and knowledge to effectuate good results...and of course I don't think this particular breeding possesses that.....but just because a kennel has generations of their stock doesn't tell you anything unless you know the particulars.
I see in this pedigree Weiss Blau dogs....now I don't know if this is Larry and Anna Parker's kennel. I thought their kennel was Weiss Blau, anyway I remember Larry and Anna when they moved to Ala. in the mid seventies from Germany. They had good dogs then, but they were both very knowledgable about the breed and they trained their dogs. I have no doubt they would make good breeding decisions, having talked to them hours on end back then. Again, I don't know that the Weiss Blau is their kennel or not(and I am not saying this is good breeding...lol), but I do know if it is them I would wager their dogs are very sound. I hope this makes sense.
|12-25-2012 12:49 PM|
Originally Posted by msvette2u View Post
|12-25-2012 11:03 AM|
Originally Posted by GSD<3er212 View Post
But you can start with fostering one dog at a time. That's how we got started!
|12-25-2012 10:59 AM|
Cliff I have no idea what you are meaning by this in conjunction with this thread ???? "Hey Carmen....you have a dogs that have a lot of generations of only your kennel ???....anyway....it is difficult to understand the breeding but it is mostly a west SL breeding with some west working"
MY line is the rudder -- the certainty - planned for generations ahead - reliable , predictable results -- low risk (conservative) , building and banking , collecting old heritage working herding genetics (not modern trial) , critically evaluating and selecting for harder to get (deliberately bred for - not random one or two in a litter) traits such as genetic obedience, high hunt search , natural instinctive tracking . I constantly bring in fresh but complementary genetics and attach them , bring them forward to the next generation. There is a plan .
the pedigree being discussed has no plan whatsoever . No testing -- just producing little doggies with 4 legs , the all important gsd prick (standing upright ears) and color .
|12-25-2012 10:59 AM|
Originally Posted by wolfstraum View Post
|12-25-2012 10:41 AM|
Nobody said you did. Obviously her previous owners did, however, and God only knows how many siblings of hers, and generations before her.
This is essentially what I was saying in my earlier posts.
The difference between what your dog's parents owners did and what good breeders do, is that good breeders look at all aspects of a dog's make up - health, temperament, working ability (yes there has to be some), and match the breeding prospects up to enhance the breed, to make sure the puppies aren't a genetic mess, temperamentally and health-wise.
This is why so many allergies and other health issues and temperament issues are becoming so rampant in the breed.
AND all breeds are subject to this, not just GSDs.
Please remember Lee was speaking in general and about your dog's parentage and lineage, not you.
This is how I often post, and it's often misunderstood in the same manner, I can relate!
|12-25-2012 10:37 AM|
Sorry - that was NOT meant to be a personal attack - just an observation on the general public who does dispose of dogs....your girl is lucky that you bought her and want to give her a loving home....she is one of the lucky ones! Big commercial operations like the one behind her are just as much to blame for the dogs who get disposed of as the people who dump them out on highways or in shelters....
As a breeder, my comments were observations and conclusions based on years of getting emails about nice looking dogs on their last hours in shelters, on the constant barrage of facebook posts looking for a reprieve for dogs bred by irresponsible people who are in trouble.....
When posts like mine, and many of the others in this thread are made, they are often read by lurkers who are also thinking about breeding - and are thus very general and made in the hopes that the information given helps people other than the OP to make an informed decision about the responsibility of breeding dogs.
|12-25-2012 10:02 AM|
Originally Posted by wolfstraum View Post
|This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.|