That's how the CGC test is...they don't have to hold her back. If you can tell your dog to stay, and hand the leash to someone else and walk away its perfectly fine. Just that they actually get a little more leeway and its not a full blown out of sight stay. The dog can switch positions...it can even stand up and walk around a bit, but the leash can't get super tight for too long I believe. So it can't look like the person is actually physically trying to prevent your dog from going to you.