German Shepherd Dog Forums

German Shepherd Dog Forums (http://www.germanshepherds.com/forum/)
-   General Information (http://www.germanshepherds.com/forum/general-information/)
-   -   Collar Horror Stories? (http://www.germanshepherds.com/forum/general-information/456818-collar-horror-stories.html)

CharlieB.Barkin 06-03-2014 10:04 PM

Collar Horror Stories?
 
While looking for a new dog collar, I have come across a lot of horror stories involving all kinds of dog collars. They typically involve a second dog getting it's jaw stuck between the collar and the neck of the first dog, or the tags on the collar getting stuck on something, like a crate, or a fence.

I don't like the idea of my dogs going about without a collar at any time, so what could be done to minimize this?

I would think that getting a name plate riveted into the collar can prevent the tags from getting stuck on anything, but my municipality gives out these registration tags, so there will still be one present regardless. I saw in a video that you could inner tube to strap them down.

When I fit my dog's collars, I like to give them a lot of space. I can usually fit 4 fingers between the collar and my dog's neck. Could this potentially put them in danger? I don't like putting them on this tight:
http://k9tacticalgear.com/sites/defa...ic/quick_4.JPG

I also hear that it's safer to use a quick release clip, as opposed to a belt style buckle. My only problem with this is that I question the durability of any plastic buckle. Especially during the winters here when it can get to -40 degrees celsius. I would only feel comfortable using a metal buckle.

Magwart 06-03-2014 10:20 PM

I lost a dog many years ago to a collar accident. We switched to Chinook Break-away collars, and don't leave anything else on the dogs. They are much safer, you can put tags on them, and you can grab both rings quickly to keep an exuberant dog from bolting, if needed. (The company has GREAT customer service -- when mine were young, they figured out how to get the collars off and use them as tug-of-war toys, and Chinook sold me replacements at a deep discount, even though it was no fault of theirs, as I had to replace them several times until the dogs tired of that game.)

Your Dog Collar Story: Chinook & Co.

onyx'girl 06-03-2014 10:23 PM

And don't forget, if you leave a leash on the collar anything can happen!
http://www.wdrb.com/story/25680209/c...-car-into-pond

CharlieB.Barkin 06-03-2014 10:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by onyx'girl (Post 5598258)
And don't forget, if you leave a leash on the collar anything can happen!
Canton, Mass. man claims puppy drove car into pond - WDRB 41 Louisville News

That's definitely a strange story. It seems more like negligence to me than anything else.

CharlieB.Barkin 06-03-2014 10:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Magwart (Post 5598242)
I lost a dog many years ago to a collar accident. We switched to Chinook Break-away collars, and don't leave anything else on the dogs. They are much safer, you can put tags on them, and you can grab both rings quickly to keep an exuberant dog from bolting, if needed. (The company has GREAT customer service -- when mine were young, they figured out how to get the collars off and use them as tug-of-war toys, and Chinook sold me replacements at a deep discount, even though it was no fault of theirs, as I had to replace them several times until the dogs tired of that game.)

Your Dog Collar Story: Chinook & Co.

Those are interesting. From reading through the website, it seems like you have to call to make an order. I wonder if they make them for toy breeds as well.

My only concern with that collar would involve it unintentionally coming undone and then the dogs are loose without a collar or identification tags. I do like this option, but are there alternatives?

Magwart 06-03-2014 11:05 PM

You want a collar that will release under pressure when you are away if the dog gets caught on something. If it doesn't do that, you haven't solved the risk. It doesn't come off easily--it requires a good, sharp tug to release. Now that our dogs are older, we only find them in the yard if there's been some serious rough-housing going on (very rare) -- and when we find one, we know the collar did what it was supposed to, since rough-housing in a collar is how we lost a dog years ago (when another dog's jaw slid under the collar, the one wearing the collar rolled, creating a figure-8 around the jaw; the harder the dog on top pulled, the more it strangled the dog on the bottom).

We microchip our dogs, too, so there's a second layer of protection in case a collar and tags come off.

You can buy them on Amazon too: . I like calling to buy them though because the customer service has been excellent.

shepherdmom 06-03-2014 11:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CharlieB.Barkin (Post 5598194)
While looking for a new dog collar, I have come across a lot of horror stories involving all kinds of dog collars. They typically involve a second dog getting it's jaw stuck between the collar and the neck of the first dog, or the tags on the collar getting stuck on something, like a crate, or a fence.

I don't like the idea of my dogs going about without a collar at any time, so what could be done to minimize this?

I would think that getting a name plate riveted into the collar can prevent the tags from getting stuck on anything, but my municipality gives out these registration tags, so there will still be one present regardless. I saw in a video that you could inner tube to strap them down.

When I fit my dog's collars, I like to give them a lot of space. I can usually fit 4 fingers between the collar and my dog's neck. Could this potentially put them in danger? I don't like putting them on this tight:
http://k9tacticalgear.com/sites/defa...ic/quick_4.JPG

I also hear that it's safer to use a quick release clip, as opposed to a belt style buckle. My only problem with this is that I question the durability of any plastic buckle. Especially during the winters here when it can get to -40 degrees celsius. I would only feel comfortable using a metal buckle.

Rolled leather was recommended to me nearly 30 years ago by a rescue. I love them. My dogs wear them 24-7. I use either a halter or martingale when we are out and about but the leather collar is always on.

http://www.petco.com/product/10973/P...-in-Black.aspx

onyx'girl 06-03-2014 11:23 PM

My 3 dogs have never worn collars when on our property. For over 7 years we've never needed a collar for their "safety".... they are all microchipped(one is also tattoo'd but that won't identify his owner/address).

I will not have them wear collars when we aren't training or they are unsupervised.
Collars and tags can get caught in floor heat vents or on drawer or cabinet pulls/handles(I've seen this happen first hand).
Truth be told, a collar won't bring my dogs safely home, none of them would willingly go up to strangers to be 'caught' if they were to stray.
I'm diligent in making sure they are always in my sight when outside and our gates are locked.
I would rather have a breakaway collar for safety than one the dog couldn't slide out of if it meant panic or worse.

selzer 06-03-2014 11:28 PM

I use a leather collar with a buckle, but I only put a collar on the dog when we are leaving the property. At home dogs are naked. Most are chipped. I haven never had a collar accident, but then, I am usually actively interacting with one dog when there is a collar on anyone.

I had a choke chain accident with my first GCD, where he fell asleep on the deck and the ring fell through the slats of the decking and he tried to stand up and couldn't. Then he panicked and circled around and around, and finally made a strangled cry. I went out there thinking he attacked someone and found him stuck to the deck. I quickly called my landlords and they rushed over, and the three of us managed to get him free.

No collars on my dogs when I am not supervising. Though I do leave rick rack or puppy collars on babies, and haven't had a problem with that.

Yet.

huntergreen 06-03-2014 11:50 PM

like those break away collars as long as the dog is chipped.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 07:19 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SEO by vBSEO 3.3.2