German Shepherd Dog Forums

German Shepherd Dog Forums (
-   General Behavior (
-   -   Car Barking Driving the Family Nuts (

Benny Boo's Mommy 03-08-2014 06:55 PM

Car Barking Driving the Family Nuts
Hello, I'm posting this as a new thread because I haven't seen anyone addressing this specific issue. My male GSD, Ben, is a good boy and doesn't bark much at home; however, he has never liked riding in the car and is now barking all the time while on car rides. He does NOT bark at other dogs/people/cars he sees. He just barks like crazy. My husband and I hypothesize that it happens when he thinks we're going to the dog park, his doggy daycare, or Petco (his three favorite places), but he also just does it most of the time he's in the car.

This is driving us nuts. We tried shaking a can with coins at him, but he just gets even more of us sometimes sits in the back with him, but we can't do that every time (and it doesn't work every time).

Any suggestions? We love our dog, but riding in the car with him is terrible.


MichaelE 03-08-2014 08:00 PM

Well, that's what dogs do. Bark.

I think he's just having a good time.

You will need to teach him the "quiet" command. You can do it with or without a clicker or treats.

Sometimes they outgrow barking in certain situations, but not always. You don't say how old he is.

Benny Boo's Mommy 03-08-2014 08:47 PM

Oh, sorry. He's a rescue from the pound. We guesstimate that he is about 13-14 months old. The vet said in October that he was around 8/9 months old (according to his teeth).

I don't think he's having a good time or just barking for fun; he often whines and does the frustration growl too. He seems terribly anxious in the car.

I will follow up with the quiet command. Hopefully that works.

MadLab 03-08-2014 09:00 PM

Go back a bit a desensitize him to the car.

Get him ready to go. Get him into the car. don't start it. Wait a few minutes. Wait until he relaxes and then bring him back to the house. Do it again and again and show him the car is not a source of stress.

When he gets used to it you can start the car. Turn it off again and bring him back to the house and repeat the exercise a few times. After some time, hours or days you can bring him a small bit in the car and bring him back to the house again.

If he is comfortable and relaxed during these processes you can treat him and praise him.

Through repetition you can retrain him to be calm in the car. It might seem strange doing these exercises but it does help. Same if a dog is barking at a boundary or at the door step.

Take a look at what energy the dog has and what energy are you nurturing in every day life. This is a sign of you not being in control of the dog so there are probably other areas where you can influence the dog to be calmer and more relaxed.

Basically imo excitement, whining and anxiousness needs to be dealt with in a very subtle manner. It is better to take your time and expect the dog to be relaxed more and never let it rush you or make you frustrated as this compounds the issues.

Calm assertive leadership as prescribed by Cesar millan does help to give you a calmer dog. You have to research it and think about it to see why this approach works.

Chip18 03-09-2014 01:58 AM


Originally Posted by MichaelE (Post 5160057)
Well, that's what dogs do. Bark.

I think he's just having a good time.

You will need to teach him the "quiet" command. You can do it with or without a clicker or treats.

Sometimes they outgrow barking in certain situations, but not always. You don't say how old he is.

Well behaved dogs do not bark in cars. None that I've trained.

Chip18 03-09-2014 05:50 PM

Just got a tip from the BoxerForum. Same deal over there. Owner took her dog in for training. Answer came back Resource guarding! Car and driver/pack member.

May or may not be the case with your dog but it sounds similar. He's just cruising down the road shouting "mine'' "mine"!

I think MadLab nailed it!

Benny Boo's Mommy 03-18-2014 11:22 PM

We definitely need to take Ben in for some training. So far we've been doing it ourselves and he's our first dog, first GSD. While he's been pretty easy to train--sits, rolls over, shakes, etc.-- he does have a lot of excitement/anxiety about going places and this is where the problem is (or one of them; the other is that he's young and very bouncy/excitable).

He is pretty quiet in the house, but needs to be in the room with people (usually me). He will follow me from room to room, even if my husband is in the living room. I usually sleep a bit later than my husband, and Ben will come out, eat, go outside to do his business, and come back to sleep by the bed until I get up. He usually starts getting SUPER excited (circling, pacing, panting, etc) when he sees us getting ready to go out. When we first got him, he would bark crazily until we opened the door so he could wait outside while we got ready. He was so afraid of getting left at home.

Now he just follows us (especially me) until we're ready to leave, then he barrels out of the house as soon as the door opens...but literally ONLY to the other side of the door. He will not get off the porch until we are ALL coming down the stairs. He literally waits for us all before he'll come out to the car port.

{some background}

We got him in October from the local animal control (pound). He had been an emaciated stray. Nobody at the pound knew anything about where he was from other than the area of the city (Atlanta). He was very sick at first, but as he got better, his real personality came out. He's very sweet, but used to be too nippy when excited (he would nip, throw himself at our feet and roll over, wanting to nip and have his tummy rubbed at the same time). He used to nip/herd A LOT in the mornings as a "good morning greeting," but we have mostly gotten him to quit that. However, he still mouths/nips our 10 yr old son on occasion when he is excited/anxious about going somewhere and sometimes does it to me when I get home from work. He has a soft mouth: never leaves marks or scratches if he nips/mouths, lets us take food and toys out of his mouth, etc. Still, we want him to stop mouthing completely. Otherwise, he's very sweet, and puts up with being hugged around the neck and squeezed by my son, etc. However, he's anxious/excited about going somewhere, every time we go anywhere.

He HATES being alone/has separation anxiety. We can't leave him at home. He either goes to daycare, or waits in the car for us if we go somewhere to dinner or something.

Since I last wrote, we've made some progress on the car barking. Now he starts barking in the car when i) our son gets dropped off (whines and barks as he watches him walk into the school); ii) when we pass by his regular (daily) dog park, the doggy daycare he goes to, or Petco (which we visit regularly). He also does a frustration growl, which doesn't seem aggressive, more complaining if that makes sense. He never shows teeth or snarls. Just makes a lot of complaining sounding vocalizing.

Lately, I've been sitting in the back while my husband drives and "biting" Ben's scruff with my fingers while saying "NO" very firmly to him when he starts barking/whining/vocalizing. He has finally started responding to this and stops the behavior! I do have to do it several times before he finally settles down. (Also, if he's been exercised he's super good in the car and just sleeps or is calm.) I'm hoping to get to a point where I can go back to the front seat instead of having to sit back there and bite him. lol

Anyway, thanks again for all the great information. I definitely think he needs to go to training so that we have a firmer hand on him and also to deal with the separation issues he has. He won't even play at the dog park if my husband leaves to get something out of the car (just waits at the corner for him to come back into sight, even if my son and I are still with him). He even barks/cries if my son runs ahead of us on a walk--he absolutely hates for any of us to leave him.

Does this stuff go away or lessen with training? Or perhaps as time goes by? I mean the anxiety of being left alone/separated. We've had him five months. Everybody in my family loves him dearly and he is a good, good pup.

Benny Boo's Mommy 03-18-2014 11:46 PM

Thanks for the advice re: Cesar Millan! I love that guy! Also, I'm definitely looking up that boxer forum. :)

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 06:58 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
vBulletin Security provided by vBSecurity v2.2.2 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2017 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2017 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.

For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome