Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Grand Rapids, MI
Shock collar and e-collar are the same thing (to me at least). If you mean a bark collar vs. e-collar, based on your post the bark collar is not going to work for you. It will shock when she barks, period, because it's activated based on the dog barking. If you want to control it (sometimes allow it and sometimes not) then you need a different tool that will allow *you* to enforce a command.