E-Collar recommendations

[elisabeth_00117]

Just looking for a recommendation for a e-collar.

The use is mainly for hiking in the bush and being off lead in high traffic areas (the park near my building that is fenced on three sides) although I may use it for training later on as well.

I am mostly at this point wanting it for the stim function as Stark has excellent recall but with the temptation of squirrels, bunnies and other critters we come across I want to ensure that I have some extra control.

I usually correct with a touch (on the shoulder) coupled with a verbal cue but if he is a distance away from me it is hard to do that.

I was looking at these:

1900NCP Dogtra Remote Training Collar, electric collar dog training, we ship worldwide - DogSport Gear

280NCP Dogtra Remote Training Collar, electric collar dog training, we ship worldwide - DogSport Gear

Anyone have any recommendations?

[MaggieRoseLee]

Electric Dog Training Collars, E-collar Batteries, Shock Collar Repair Services-Reconditioned Remote Trainers is my favorite place to get e-collars. And if you get a reconditioned one it's a huge savings and they come like new. PLUS very good customer service.

I like the Tritronics Sports Reconditioned Tri-Tronics Sport Basic G3
but Dogtra is another good brand.

[Jax's Mom]

I'd go with the 1900 (if you do end up buying from that company, please let me know how it goes, I need a new one).
I have just a cheap one right now that does the job but doesn't have many features. The next one I get must be rechargeable (battieries for those suckers are like $20), waterproof and have a battery level indicator (nothin' better than buying a new battery just to find out someone (not gonna name names) messed with the settings).

[zyppi]

I have the Dogtra 282 ( same as 280 but the two dog model). I've found it very reliable and I like the variation of levels of stim plus the vibrate.

[Packen]

Different models "hit" differently. In technical terms the rise/fall times and the dwell times of the wave are different. Based on the dog's temperament one will suit better than the other. In layman's terms one will feel like a pin prick to a razor blade while the other will feel like a soft nudge to a sledge hammer based on the level. This makes the difference between instant aggression or compliance depending on the temperament of the dog.

Without knowing the dog, best way is to try different models while someone experienced uses the leash to pair with the electric. Based on the results you make a selection. Definitely get someone experienced to help you teach the dog how to get out of the pressure.

The Dogtra's are like pin pricks, the Tritronics like nudges, Schecker like a sledge hammer. Each will suit a particular temperament type more than the other.

[elisabeth_00117]

Thanks everyone.

Originally Posted by Packen

Different models "hit" differently. In technical terms the rise/fall times and the dwell times of the wave are different. Based on the dog's temperament one will suit better than the other. Without knowing the dog, best way is to try different models while someone experienced uses the leash to pair with the electric. Based on the results you make a selection. Definitely get someone experienced to help you teach the dog how to get out of the pressure.

I will definitely get someone to help me choose but I am ordering it online because there isn't anywhere to purchase them in my area.

[Packen]

I meant try different models used by your club members then make a selection based on results. With some dogs having 2 receivers get much better results as compared to using 1 receiver. Some dogs instinctively move towards the stim, some move away, you can counter the lateral response by using 2 recievers on each side of the neck, or use 1 to help with the particular exercise based on the directional response. Just different options to consider/learn before ordering.

[Jason L]

Ah the good old Schecker sledge hammer!

Ike's "regular" e-collar is the tri-tronics with two receivers (on each side of the neck like Packen described).

[phgsd]

I have the 1900...although I lost the transmitter about 6 months ago and need to order a new one
But it is a great collar, I have no complaints, and their customer service is very good too.
If you search around you might be able to find it a little cheaper...I found this one for 210...
Dogtra 1900 Ncp Training Collar, Dogtra Field Star Electronic Dog Training Kit

[Syaoransbear]

I also have the 1900NCP and I've got no complaints. It's a great collar. I love how my dog can go swimming with it on and I don't have to worry.