I get them occasionally. Mostly the berry ones because they're one of the few biscuit treats that have that really strong berry smell that Kaiju goes nuts for. It does have grains which I normally don't feed, but I love to chow down on a carton of oreos every now and then, so I feel like I can begrudge Kaiju some sweet berry crack biscuits every now and then. I don't think I'd use them for training. I like smaller treats maybe a third that size and chewy so they don't interrupt the flow of training. But they are good to put in puzzle toys, Kongs, and to play the cup guessing game with.