Dry Food - Best? Fromm, Science Diet, Eukanuba???

[Magwart]

I rotate among the Fromm 4-star flavors, and my dogs are doing great. The Whitefish kibble honestly looks like cat food (little crosses instead of pebbles)--I did a double-take the first time I opened the bag. The dogs love it though. The love all of them. The only one of this line I won't buy is the Pork & Applesauce--it seemed to give two of them runny poo. Usually the poo is nice and solid with this food. I think with an allergic dog I'd feed the Whitefish kibble over the others.

[Kaluig]

Awesome! I am going to buy the duck w/ sweet potato first and then I will try the salmon despite the kibble size being small, how about the grain free beef fritatta?

[3ToesTonyismydog]

I believe Orijen is the best dog food made today, but there are quite a few good ones out there. Here is a couple of list's I made up quite some time ago. I really have been thinking about taking Wellness off the list because of all the issues with this dog food.


Orijen, Acana, Horizon Legacy, Fromm, Merrick, Go Endurance, Precise Holistic, Wellness Core, Castor and Pollux Natural, Eathborn Holistic, Evo, Go Fit and Free, Instinct, Pinnacle Peak, Solid Gold, Canidea, Darford Zero/G, Now Grain Free....


Pulsar, Blue Wilderness, Artemis, First Mate. Natures Logic, Nutrisourse, Exclusive, Pure Vita, Wellness, Earthborn, Annamaet, Organix, Whole Earth Farms, Premium Edge, By Nature grain free, Victor, TOTW,

[Kaluig]

Thanks for a very comprehensive dog food list. I heard good things about Fromm and I want to try it on Igor now. With so many welness options available in the market, and your list attested for that, I would not remove this welness section at all, it is very informative for newbies as we can learn what did and did not work from each dog owner as well as get some important tips; at the same time, I can understand some experts might not find this section as helpful.

[RedR327]

Originally Posted by Kaluig

Thanks for a very comprehensive dog food list. I heard good things about Fromm and I want to try it on Igor now. With so many welness options available in the market, and your list attested for that, I would not remove this welness section at all, it is very informative for newbies as we can learn what did and did not work from each dog owner as well as get some important tips; at the same time, I can understand some experts might not find this section as helpful.

If you go with Fromm stick with Fromm Gold or Fromm Classic. Nothing in the 4 Star Foods justifies the price.

[Kaluig]

I looked into the Gold and Classic but they all have chicken in the ingredients and I am trying to test a no chicken base food for now. I bought Blue lamb & brown rice today and he seemed to like, just a small bag until the Fromm bags arrive.