Not that either took are not effective, but it is my opinion that your pup would be best served learning to be more confident. If she is barking out if fear, couple that with an ill timed ecollar correction and now the dog us scared and getting in trouble fir being scared. So now she may think, if she gets shocked every time she sees a kid, that kids bring bad things. Making her fear worse.
Sent from Petguide.com Free App
"So that others may live"