If anyone has any experience with either of these foods, we'd love to hear what you think!
I rotate my dogs through the Fromm 4 Star flavors, as they're designed to work as a rotation diet, without having to transition gradually between them. I love how my dogs are doing on Fromm.
More than that, I'm very happy with the company's ethics -- it's family owned, and they manufacture their food in their own factory (i.e., they don't contract out to Diamond or some factory that makes 20 other brands of food). My understanding is that they've also never had a recall -- compare that to record to SG:
Solid Gold Dog Food Recall
Pet Food Recall 2012 List: Diamond Dog Food, Kirkland, Solid Gold and More! | Foodbeat