Originally Posted by HarleyTheGSD
I took both of my GSDs outside every 20-30 minutes when they were pups. When they finished eating and drinking I took them outside after 5 minutes. If they pottied in the house I scolded them and put them outside. Varick has been potty trained since about 6 months and has had only 3 accidents in the house altogether.
We have been doing everything you mentioned. But sometimes I find random puddles and I don't feel like I can punish her unless she is caught in the act. I know it will take times it is just frustrating sometimes.